Researching Dealers
During the twentieth century, dealers continued to play an important role in the antiquities art market, working directly with private collectors and museums while also supplying objects to the major auction houses. A brief perusal of advertisements in The Burlington Magazine, Apollo, Art in America, and similar publications indicates the vast scale and scope of this international market. Keeping track of individual dealers can be overwhelming, especially since a gallery might move to a new location, adopt a new focus, or have a change in ownership. Even for well-known dealers, it can be difficult to verify biographical details, addresses, active dates, and archives. Fortunately, research institutions have compiled general lists that offer a good starting point and, for more obscure figures, annual dealer guides can be useful (see “Types of Archives” in Chapter 2 and “Dealer Directories” in Appendix 1).1 Although focused on Egypt, Frederick Hagen and Kim Ryholt’s The Antiquities Trade in Egypt 1880–1930: The H. O. Lange Papers offers valuable context for the Egyptian art market, including an appendix of more than two hundred dealers.2 A handful of early to mid-twentieth-century dealer records are available for in-person study, and hopefully more archives will be digitized, as the Brummer Gallery Records have, but such accessible resources remain in the minority. It is also worth keeping in mind the shifting historic and economic contexts of this period, including world wars dispersing collections and uprooting collectors and dealers, and New York gaining prominence as an art market center. The mid- to late twentieth-century market is even less well documented. Records, if preserved at all, may still be with the gallery or family of the dealer. For these, advertisements, exhibition checklists, and catalogues can offer a helpful, albeit highly fragmented, view of a specific dealer or gallery. In this section, we hope to provide a fuller picture of the art market through brief biographies of individual dealers, who serve as windows into a large and complex network.
Illicit Trade of Antiquities
In discussing dealers in antiquities, the full context of the art market in the twentieth century must be acknowledged—notably, the continued widespread trade of illicit antiquities, discussed also by Rose in this volume. Despite export laws and the stricter regulation of excavations, individuals supplied the market with recently found and looted objects for many years, and a network of dealers and middlemen has now been well documented.3 It has now been well documented that there existed a network of dealers and middlemen engaged in trading recently found and looted objects. Through these channels, illegally excavated artifacts continued to enter the art market to join objects that had been circulating for years. The trade’s tradition of discretion and anonymity allowed works, both illicit and legitimate, to have their histories easily falsified and obscured, or simply omitted. The presence of illicitly excavated material on the art market was openly acknowledged and generally accepted as business as usual. A 1971 guide for collectors stated outright that “there is no denying that nearly all fresh finds offered to the collector have left their lands of origin illicitly,” and only cautions that these “clandestinely excavated” antiquities should best be purchased outside of their country of origin.4 Some of the dealers discussed below are known to have been involved in the illegal trafficking of antiquities. A key piece of evidence for this is an organizational chart recovered in a raid by the Italian Carabinieri that names tombaroli (Italian for “tomb-robbers,” referring to those operating in Italy) and antiquities dealers, including the following individuals: Robert Hecht, Gianfranco Becchina, Giacomo Medici, Elie Borowski, Nicolas Koutoulakis, George Ortiz, and Frieda Tchacos.5 Although not identified on the organizational chart, hereafter called the “organigram,” other individuals including Robin Symes and Fritz Bürki have been implicated in court cases and through the repatriation of objects they sold to museums and private collections. It is worth noting that many of these dealers also bought and sold legitimate antiquities from well-documented collections, but given their connections to illicit networks, anything that may have passed through their hands should be carefully reviewed.
We have identified a selection of prolific and notable dealers active in the twentieth century whose sales are represented in public and private collections. Far from a comprehensive list, the following represent a cross section of the antiquities market, and we found them to be most pertinent to our research.6 For a deeper dive, dealer memoirs and collectors’ guides offer an internal view of the art market; often sensational, these accounts should be considered with a degree of skepticism.7
There is some overlap between this list and “Dealers” (in Appendix 1), with some figures present in both (e.g., Joseph and Ernest Brummer, André Emmerich, and Dikran Kelekian). This list does not include well-known late nineteenth-century dealers (e.g., the Jandolo family, nor the twentieth-century dealers for whom we have found little to no documented information).
Biographies
Becchina, Gianfranco
b. 1938, active 1970s–90s. Galerie Palladion (also known as Antike Kunst Palladion, Palladion Antike Kunst); Palladion Ancient and Fine Art AG; all Basel, Switzerland
Address Rennweg 51, Basel, Switzerland (1970s)
Born and raised in Sicily (Castelvetrano), Becchina moved to Basel in the 1970s, where he sold antiquities to dealers, private collectors, museums, and auction houses through his gallery, Galerie Palladion (one catalogue was produced in 1976, together with limited advertisements in publications such as Apollo and Weltkunst in the mid- to late 1970s). Becchina is known to have obscured his sources through aliases, such as “Anna Spinello” (his sister’s married name),8 and falsified provenances, notably the “Lauffenbruger collection” for the Getty Kouros9 and the collection of a “Karl Haug” in Basel (with Hotel Helvetia letterhead) for works that have since been returned to Italy.10 In the mid-1990s Becchina moved back to Castelvetrano, while his wife Ursula (née Juraschek; known as “Rosie”) remained in Switzerland.11 Becchina’s name appears on the organigram, and he has been charged in Italy of conspiracy and dealing in stolen antiquities.12 The Carabinieri and Swiss police raided Becchina’s facilities in 2002 (and 2005), recovering thousands of objects, photographs, and documentation. Becchina’s confiscated archives contain evidence for ongoing investigations, so these documents have not yet been made public, but they have been shared with select law enforcement and researchers.13 The Becchina dossier confirms that Becchina sold mostly through Sotheby’s London, with some works sold through Christie’s London, and that he maintained close relations with dealers George Ortiz and Jerome Eisenberg as well as institutions like the Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York (Dietrich von Bothmer); the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston; Cleveland Museum of Art (Arielle Kozlov); and the Louvre.14
Borowski, Elie
1913–2003, active 1950s–80s. Gallery in Basel, Switzerland; Galerie Archéologie, Paris, France
Addresses 25 Admiral Road, Toronto, Ontario, Canada (ca. 1950s); Archéologie Classique et du Proche-Orient, Angensteinerstrasse 7, Basel, Switzerland (ca. 1960s–); Galerie Archéologie, 40 Rue du Bac, Paris (ca. late 1960s–)15
Borowski, born in Warsaw, Poland, was a specialist in Near Eastern art. He received his doctoral degree from the University of Geneva in 1946 and then moved to Toronto in 1948 for a fellowship with the Royal Ontario Museum. He worked as a consultant for ancient art dealers and collectors, meanwhile building up a personal collection, and in the late 1950s he set up his own gallery in Basel, Switzerland, with a subsidiary in Paris. Borowski advertised both locations in publications like The Burlington Magazine, L’Oeil, catalogues produced for the Biennale des Antiquaires (organized by the Syndicat National des Antiquaires) and later in Apollo and Antike Kunst (primarily 1960s) specializing in classical and Near Eastern archaeology. The Paris branch operated under Nina Borowski in the 1970s–80s until she moved the gallery to Geneva in 1995 (16, rue de la Corraterie).16 Borowski sold objects to museums and private collectors especially in North America and Europe, and his personal collection has been exhibited, partially sold at auctions, and donated to museums.17 Dieter Widmer (1918–2011) photographed works for Borowski in Basel, and this photo archive has been preserved (see Dieter Widmer in Appendix 1, under “Dealers”). Borowski’s name appears in the organigram, connecting him to Robert Hecht.18 In 1985 Borowski and his wife Batya (née Weiss) founded the Bible Lands Museum in Jerusalem for his collection, and they moved to Jerusalem upon the museum’s opening in 1992. After his death in 2003, Borowski’s personal collection continued to be published by specialists; a memoir, based on interviews and edited by John Boardman, was published in 2017.19
Brummer, Joseph
1883–1947, and brothers Imre Brummer (1889–1928) and Ernest Brummer (1891–1964), active 1920s–40s. The Brummer Gallery, Paris and New York
Addresses Brummer Frères / Brummer Curiosités, 3 Boulevard Raspail, Paris (1911–20s); 36 rue de Miromesnil, Paris (1920s); 27 East 57th Street, New York (1920s); 53 East 57th Street, New York (and other locations)
Joseph and his brothers Imre and Ernest were art dealers, originally from Austria-Hungary. Joseph relocated to Paris and founded the Brummer Gallery in 1906. Imre and Ernest joined Joseph in Paris in 1911, and in 1914 Joseph and Imre moved to New York to establish an American branch, which opened in 1920.20 Over the next four decades, the Brummers acquired and sold thousands of objects, including African art, classical and pre-Hispanic antiquities, art of the Middle Ages, Baroque and Renaissance decorative arts, and works of modern art. Clients included private collectors, dealers, universities, and museums in Europe and America. Their gallery played a large role in building the collections of Henry Walters, William Randolph Hearst, Grenville Winthrop, and the Metropolitan Museum of Art. Joseph maintained the New York gallery until his death in 1947, and his personal collection was sold by Parke-Bernet in 1949.21 After Ernest Brummer’s death, part of his collection was sold at auction in 1964, a selection of medieval works was acquired by Duke University in 1966, and his widow, Ella Baché Brummer, sold the rest at auction in 1979.22 While the catalogues of these later auctions sometimes include some provenance information, the Brummer Gallery records, which have been partly digitized by the Metropolitan Museum, include accession cards and inventories with detailed purchase and sale history notes.23 With increased access, studies on the archive have been presented and published; and works connected to the Brummer Gallery continue to appear on the art market (see Joseph Brummer in Appendix 1, under “Dealers”).24
Brun, Jeannette
Active late 1950s–80s, also as Jeanette Brun; Jeannette G. Brun. Zurich
Address 119 Dufourstrasse, Zurich, Switzerland; 15 rue des Grands Augustins, Paris, France (by 1960s)25
Earliest advertisements in the late 1950s describe Brun’s gallery as focusing on sculpture, but by the 1960s she was carrying a broad general stock of classical antiquities, specializing in high-quality Greek, Roman, and Etruscan works. Brun advertised widely in European and American publications (Apollo, The Art Quarterly, The Burlington Magazine, L’Oeil, Antike Kunst, Die Weltkunst) and sold primarily to institutions, museums, and high-profile collectors.26
Cahn, Herbert
1915–2002, active 1940s–80s. Münzen und Medaillen AG, Basel; H. A. C. Kunst der Antike, Basel (1988–)
Address Malzgasse 25, Basel, Switzerland
Herbert Cahn, a numismatist, professor of ancient art, and coin dealer, was born in Frankfurt am Main to a family with a long history in numismatics. Cahn’s grandfather, Adolph E. Cahn (1839–1918) had established a coin dealer house by 1890, later managed by Cahn’s father Ludwig Theodor Cahn (1877–1924). Herbert and his brother Erich (1913–1993) relocated to Switzerland in 1933, where they each established numismatic firms and in 1942 jointly founded Münzen und Medaillen AG Basel, which became one of the most important dealers of ancient coins. The firm also sold antiquities, with extensively researched scholarly catalogues specializing in Greek antiquities, terracottas, and decorated vases. To reach American buyers, Cahn partnered with the André Emmerich Gallery in New York, presenting several sale exhibitions between 1965 and 1970. He helped establish the journal Antike Kunst in Basel in 1956 (published 1958 to the present) and, with Leo Mildenberg, the series Typos (1975–82). Cahn also maintained a personal collection of vase fragments, acquired from the 1950s onward, which have been published and exhibited.27 Cahn established his own ancient art firm in 1988, H. A. C. Kunst der Antike, which his son Jean-David Cahn took over and absorbed into his own company, Galerie Cahn, in 1999; this is still active and retains the firm’s archives from 1930, with significant holdings from 1954–86.28 Herbert Cahn acquired from art dealers in Italy, and in 1961 he was charged with receiving stolen property. According to Robert Hecht’s memoir, Cahn had bought objects from dealers in Rome and “did not realize or did not want to realize” he was dealing in contraband.29
Ede, Charles
1921–2002, active 1960s–80s. London
Addresses Charles Ede Ltd., 37 Brook Street, London (1971–2014); 1 Three Kings’ Yard, London (2014–); https://www.charlesede.com
Charles Ede, born in Kent, England, focused in his early career on publishing and fine art sales. In 1947 he founded the Folio Society, a publisher of literary classics in affordable editions, sold by mail-order membership. With the success of the Folio Society, Ede established the Collector’s Corner (later Folio Fine Art) in 1960, an offshoot mail-order catalogue that offered manuscript leaves, Old Master prints, and occasionally antiquities.30 Gradually, these catalogues shifted to focus more on ancient art.31 In 1971 Ede sold his publishing firm and became a full-time antiquities dealer, establishing his gallery, Charles Ede Ltd., and in 1976 published an introductory guide to collecting, primarily for collectors of limited means.32 Ede produced more than two hundred mail order catalogues, some specializing in specific areas like Roman glass, ancient writing, Cypriot pottery, small sculpture from Egypt, Greek and Roman terracottas, and Athenian pottery. Ede’s son James Ede, who began working for the gallery in 1977, was appointed managing director in 1986. Charles Ede continued to contribute research to acquisitions and catalogues until his death in 2002. The gallery continues to operate as Charles Ede Antiquities Gallery and regularly produces sales catalogues.
Eisenberg, Jerome M.
1930–2022, active 1950s–2020. Royal-Athena Galleries, New York
Addresses 107 West 43rd Street (1960s), 1066 Madison Avenue (1970s), 153 East 57th Street (–2020), all New York; https://royalathena.com
Based in New York City, Eisenberg started selling ancient coins in 1942 through his father Samuel A. Eisenberg’s coin business, Sage Coin Company, also known as Royal Coin Company; Samuel founded Sage Coin Company and Royal-Athena Galleries in Miami, ca. 1958. Jerome subsequently opened Royal-Athena Galleries in New York, initially specializing in ancient coins and broadening to antiquities more generally by 1954 (earliest catalogues published 1956; Art of the Ancient World catalogues published 1965–2019, vols. 1–30). As the gallery’s director, Eisenberg traveled regularly to Europe, Egypt, and the Near East, purchasing from local dealers, agents, and auction houses. In the 1970s Eisenberg also opened a gallery for wide-ranging collectibles (Collector’s Cabinet, 143 East 57th Street, New York)33 and worked with Alex G. Malloy, a coin collector and dealer of minor arts with a shop in New York (active 1970–80). Royal-Athena set up additional offices in London (with B.A. Seaby Ltd.) and in Beverly Hills, California. According to his gallery’s website, Eisenberg purchased more than forty thousand antiquities and sold eight hundred works to museums in the United States and Europe.34 The gallery advertised itself as offering a wide range of antiquities, from museum-quality pieces to minor arts, at competitive prices. Royal-Athena Galleries closed in 2020, and the remaining inventory was transferred to Hixenbaugh Ancient Art Ltd., New York.35
Emmerich, André
1924–2007, active 1954–98. André Emmerich Gallery; André Emmerich Inc., New York (1954–98); Zurich (1972–96)
Addresses 18 East 77th Street (–1954), 17 East 64th Street (1956–59), 41 East 57th Street (1959–98), 420 West Broadway (1971–98), all New York; https://www.emmerichgallery.com
Born in Germany, Emmerich immigrated to the United States in 1940 and in 1954 established his New York gallery, specializing in classical antiquities and pre-Hispanic art. In the 1960s the gallery expanded to include contemporary painting and sculpture. Emmerich’s gallery hosted exhibitions on pre-Hispanic and Mediterranean antiquities from the 1960s onward, and for some partnered with Herbert Cahn of Münzen und Medaillen, AG.36 The Emmerich archives, held by Archives of American Art at the Smithsonian Institution, include correspondence and object lists related to the exhibitions, catalogues, and sales (see André Emmerich in Appendix 1, under “Dealers”).37
Fallani, Giorgio
1921–1994, and son Carlo-Maria Fallani, active 1970s–present. Fallani, Rome; Antichità Archeologia Numismatica, Rome
Address Via del Babuino 58A, Rome
Giorgio Fallani was born in Rome to a family with a long history in the antiquities trade. Fallani’s great-uncle, Oreste Fallani, founded Galleria Fallani in Rome in 1872. From the 1920s the family operated a gallery at Via del Babuino, 58, with Giorgio managing the business from the 1950s.38 His son Carlo-Maria Fallani joined the business in 1969 and took over management after his father’s death in 1994. The business is still active at its Rome address; it does not produce sales catalogues or have a website.39
Hecht, Robert Emmanuel
1919–2012, active 1950s–90s; also as Bob Hecht, or REH. Rome (1947–early 1970s); Hesperia Art, New York (1950s–70s); Paris (1974–2012); Atlantis Antiquities Ltd., New York (1984–late 1990s); Hesperia Arts Auction, New York (1990)
Addresses Hesperia Art, 300 East 57th Street, New York; Atlantis Antiquities Ltd., 40 East 69th Street, New York
Robert Hecht, from Baltimore, Maryland, studied classics at Haverford College until 1941 and in 1946 began graduate studies at the University of Zurich. In 1947 he accepted a two-year fellowship at the American Academy in Rome and remained in Rome to become an antiquities dealer full-time. He made his first major sales in the early 1950s, including the collection of Ludwig Curtius (1874–1954), the former director of the Deutsches Archäologisches Institut (German Archaeological Institute) in Rome, and a South Italian vase to the Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York (50.11.4).40 While residing in Rome, around 1951 Hecht established a small antiquities firm in New York, Hesperia Art. A few years later he partnered with George R. Allen of Philadelphia to produce The Hesperia Art Bulletin (1957–72): sales catalogues of minor antiquities and coins, which Hecht wrote and Allen distributed.41 Although based in Rome until the early 1970s and then Paris from 1974, Hecht moved constantly between his so-called “source countries”: Turkey, Italy, Greece, and Lebanon, and the markets of Munich, Zurich, London, and New York. Famously, in 1972 Hecht sold the Euphronios krater (see fig. 5) to the Metropolitan Museum; the vase was restituted to Italy in 2006.42 Fritz Bürki, the Zurich-based conservator who restored the Euphronios krater, worked for Hecht and Giacomo Medici as a restorer and dealer. Hecht started working with Bruce McNall in 1975, supplying antiquities to his Beverly Hills, California, firms Numismatic Fine Arts and Summa Gallery. In the 1980s Hecht partnered with financier and collector Jonathan Rosen to operate his own gallery, Atlantis Antiquities, in New York.43 In addition to these public ventures, Hecht sold directly to museums and private collectors, and also served as a middleman for others active in the market.44 Hecht was regularly under investigation for selling illicit antiquities both in Italy (between 1961 and 1978 with Herbert Cahn and George Ortiz, and between 2005 and 2012 with Marion True; he was banned from the country 1973–82) and in Türkiye (banned from the country 1968–80). His name appears at the center of the organigram, connecting him to Gianfranco Becchina and Giacomo Medici, who are known to have been involved in the trafficking of looted antiquities, and also the dealers Elie Borowski, Nicolas Koutoulakis, George Ortiz, and Frieda Tchacos. Hecht died in Paris in 2012.
Kelekian, Dikran G.
1868–1951, active 1880s–1950, also as Dikran Khan Kélékian. Istanbul, Paris, London, Cairo
Addresses Le Musée de Bosphore, 303 Fifth Avenue, New York; 10 rue Rossini and 2 Place Vendôme, Paris; 709 Fifth Avenue, 598 Madison Avenue, 20 East 57th Street, and 32 East 69th Street, all New York
Born in Kayseri, Türkiye, and of Armenian heritage, Dikran Garabed Kelekian was a collector and dealer of ancient, medieval, Chinese, and Islamic art. He was based in Constantinople, now Istanbul, from 1885 until the 1890s, when he moved to Paris to continue his studies, opening a gallery there in 1891.45 Dikran opened another gallery in Istanbul with his brother Kevork Kelekian the following year. In 1893 he traveled to the United States for the World’s Columbian Exposition in Chicago, serving as the commissioner of the Persian Pavilion. In 1902 he was appointed consul of Persia in New York and ran a gallery known as Le Musée de Bosphore out of his consulate office on Fifth Avenue. He established additional galleries in London and Cairo, while maintaining a personal collection of Islamic art, textiles, ceramics, and modern French paintings.46 He advised major collectors, many with museum connections, notably Henry Walters, Isabella Stewart Gardner, Charles Lang Freer, and Metropolitan Museum of Art president George Blumenthal and donors Harry and Louisine Havemeyer, among others.47 After Dikran’s death in 1951, his son Charles Dikran Kelekian (1900–1982) managed the New York business. The Kelekian archives are held by the Metropolitan Museum in New York, and additional correspondences are preserved in other archives (see Dikran G. Kelekian in Appendix 1, under “Dealers”).48
Klejman, John Jacob
1906–1995, active 1950–74. J. J. Klejman Gallery, New York
Addresses 8 West 56th Street, New York (early 1950s); 982 Madison Avenue, New York (late 1950s–1970s)
Born in Poland, Klejman grew up in Warsaw and completed his studies in African art at the Sorbonne in Paris.49 He returned to Warsaw and ran an art gallery specializing in European decorative arts, which was closed during World War II when Klejman and his family were forced to live in the Jewish ghetto. After the war, he reopened the shop in Warsaw at a different location, but in 1947 left with his family and lived in Sweden, then Mexico. In 1950 Klejman settled in New York and opened a gallery that offered African and Oceanic art as well as Mediterranean antiquities. Klejman sold to private collectors like Nelson Rockefeller, John and Dominique de Menil, and John F. Kennedy, and museums including the Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, and Cleveland Museum of Art. Famously, Klejman and the Swiss dealer George Zachos sold the Lydian Hoard, also known as the Karun Treasure, to the Metropolitan Museum in the late 1960s, as discussed in Rose’s chapter in this volume. The treasure had been looted from a tomb in the Uşak region of Türkiye in 1966, but Klejman claimed he purchased it that year in two European cities from “traders.”50 After nearly ten years of legal disputes, the museum agreed to return the objects in 1993.51 According to Robert Hecht’s memoir, in at least one instance Klejman acted as a middleman for George Ortiz, who bought objects from illicit antiquities traffickers in Italy, to sell an Etruscan bronze candelabrum to the Metropolitan Museum.52 Diagnosed with Alzheimer’s in the 1970s, Klejman retired by 1976, and his business records have not been preserved.
Komor, Mathias
1909–1984, active 1930s–1984. Komor Gallery, New York
Address 19 East 71st Street, New York
Born in Hungary, Komor received his doctorate from the University of Grenoble in France and worked as an art dealer in Beijing in the 1930s, until the outbreak of World War II forced him to relocate to the United States.53 In 1941 he established a New York gallery that specialized in Chinese antiquities, Japanese painting, art of the ancient Mediterranean, and African art. Komor had connections to the Asian antiquities trade through his time with Kuhn & Komor, a long-established firm founded by a family relation. One of the few New York dealers to sell antiquities from Asia, Europe, Africa, and the Americas, the gallery sold to a range of clientele, including museums, notably the Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, and the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston. The gallery was active until Komor’s death in 1984. Although the gallery’s business records are not preserved, selections of the photographic archives, with limited annotations, and some associated papers are held by the Getty Research Institute (GRI) in Los Angeles (see Mathias Komor in Appendix 1, under “Dealers”).54 The bulk of this archive contains photographs of objects that the gallery purchased and sold, with additional photographs for study and comparison.
Koutoulakis, Nicolas
1910–1996, active ca. 1950–90s. Paris and Geneva
Addresses 4 Rue de l’Échelle, Paris (address of Galerie Ségrédakis; used by Koutoulakis ca. 1950–70s); 3 Chemin de Conches, Geneva, Switzerland (ca. 1960s–90s)
Born in Greece, Koutoulakis moved to Paris in 1922, where he joined his uncle, art dealer Emmanuel (Manolis) J. Ségrédakis (1890–1948), the owner of Galerie Ségrédakis. After inheriting his uncle’s gallery, Koutoulakis based his operations in both Paris and Geneva, eventually settling in Geneva and specializing in antiquities, notably Cycladic, Greek, Roman, and Egyptian. In the 1960s he acquired many objects from the collection of Louis de Clercq (1836–1901) through de Clercq’s heir Henri de Boisgelin.55 Around the same time, he owned Cycladic material later associated with the Keros hoard.56 In Geneva, Koutoulakis often used the art photography studio of Gad Borel-Boissonas to produce photographs of objects for potential buyers. He advised private collectors and art historians, including Charles Gillet, J. Paul Getty, Norbert Schimmel, George Ortiz, Leon Levy, Dietrich von Bothmer, Bernard V. Bothmer, and Bernard Ashmole, and he sold and donated objects to museums in North America and Europe.57 Koutoulakis’s name appears in the organigram, connecting him to the trade of illicit antiquities; some works from his collection have been repatriated.58 His wife Mireille Thîlot (1924–1996) and their three children, Emmanuel, Ariane, and Daphne, are associated with works from his collection. In the 1990s his daughter Daphne Koutoulakis opened her own gallery in Geneva, Galerie Khnoum, and remained active in the art trade.59 Koutoulakis’s advertisements (not illustrated) appeared in Antike Kunst, but he did not produce sales catalogues nor retain records; institutions and private collectors may hold archived correspondences.60
McNall, Bruce
b. 1950, active 1970s–90s. Numismatic Fine Arts, Encino, California; Beverly Hills, California (1970–90); Summa Galleries, Beverly Hills, California (1974–90); Athena Fund I, Athena Fund II, and Numismatic Fine Arts World Coin Fund (ancient art limited partnerships) (1986–90); Hesperia Arts Auction Ltd., New York (1990)
Address Summa Galleries, 342 North Rodeo Drive, Beverly Hills, California
A Los Angeles native, Bruce McNall started collecting coins at a young age while working at a small coin shop. McNall continued building up a collection as an investment while a student at the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) and started working for the coin dealer Joel Malter.61 McNall traveled to Europe and made connections with dealers, notably Leo Mildenberg and Robert Hecht, while supplying coins to Los Angeles collectors and investors, notably Seymour (Sy) Weintraub.62 By 1970, Joel Malter had bought the established mail-order coin firm Numismatic Fine Arts from Edward Gans, and in 1974 McNall bought the business name for his own coin firm. That same year he partnered with Robert Hecht to found Summa Gallery in Beverly Hills, offering a wider range of antiquities. Jane Cody, a University of Southern California (USC) classics professor and McNall’s wife by 1983, wrote sales catalogues for Summa Galleries from 1978 to 1984. In his memoir McNall admits that he was well aware of Hecht’s connections to smugglers and middlemen and acknowledges his own role in moving illicit antiquities.63 Through Summa Gallery, McNall sold to private collectors, notably Nelson Bunker Hunt and Herbert Hunt,64 and museums including the Getty Museum, Cleveland Museum of Art, and Museum of Fine Arts, Boston. In 1990 he revived Robert Hecht’s New York business Hesperia Art, with partner Jonathan Rosen, as Hesperia Arts Auction Ltd., for a special sale, with Summa Gallery, Atlantis Antiquities, and Athena Fund as major consignors.65 McNall broadened his business investments to television, race horses, and sports teams, but ultimately he overvalued various assets and in 1997 was convicted of bank fraud and conspiracy.
Medici, Giacomo
b. 1938, active 1960s–90s. Antiquaria Romana, Rome (1968–78); Hydra Galerie, also known as Galerie Hydra, Geneva (1983–90s)
Addresses Antiquaria Romana, Via del Babuino 94, Rome; Hydra Galerie, 2 Grand-Rue, Geneva
Giacomo Medici was born in Rome. His parents ran a stall at the Piazza Borghese market, selling minor antiquities from nearby excavations, both permitted and illicit.66 Building on his family’s connections, Giacomo established himself as a professional antiquities dealer; in the 1960s he supplied artifacts to Pesciotti, a pharmacist and collector in Rome, and quickly branched out to international networks.67 In 1968 Medici opened a gallery in Rome, Antiquaria Romana, which he ran for ten years. Medici met the well-established dealer Robert Hecht in the late 1960s and eventually became Hecht’s “faithful supplier.”68 In 1971 Medici reportedly bought the illegally excavated Euphronios krater from tombaroli (tomb raiders), and shortly thereafter sold it to Hecht in Switzerland.69 In the late 1970s Medici partnered with Christian Boursaud of Geneva to consign antiquities at Sotheby’s London, and in 1983 they opened Hydra Gallerie in Geneva.70 Medici bought Editions Services in 1986 and used other front companies, including Mat Securitas and Arts Franc, to sell and buy works through Sotheby’s.71 Provenances were fabricated, notably the fictitious “Zbinden collection,” which was used for fragments of a kylix sold to the Getty Museum (85.AE.385, which joined to 83.AE.362, deaccessioned in 1999) and other objects consigned to Sotheby’s.72 Medici had close connections to Robin Symes, and even shared a Geneva business address (7 Avenue Krieg) with Symes’s off-shore firm Xoilan Trader Inc. In 1995 authorities raided Medici’s Freeport warehouses in Geneva and discovered more than four thousand photographs documenting objects, many recently unearthed, that passed through Medici’s inventory.73 Giacomo Medici’s name appears prominently on the organigram, a main branch linking illicit antiquities and the art market, and he was convicted in 2004 of trafficking illegally excavated artifacts.
Merrin, Edward H.
1928–2020. Edward H. Merrin Gallery; The Merrin Gallery, New York
Address 724 5th Avenue, New York (current)
Born in Brooklyn, Edward Merrin first worked for his father’s jewelry company and in 1963 founded his own art gallery focusing on pre-Hispanic and classical antiquities. Merrin advertised extensively in Apollo, Connoisseur, and The New York Times, and exhibited at the Winter Antiques Show in New York. He bought from antiquities dealers, including directly from Gianfranco Becchina, and some works sold by Merrin were found to have been illegally excavated and have recently been subject to seizure and repatriation.74 Merrin’s son Samuel Merrin (b. 1963) took over as director in 1987. The gallery is still active and produces sales catalogues.75
Mildenberg, Leo
1913–2001, active 1950–80s, with Bank Leu AG, Zurich
Address Bank Leu, Bahnhofstrasse 32, Zurich, Switzerland76
Born in Kassel, Germany, Mildenberg studied ancient history and Semitic languages in Frankfurt until the outbreak of World War II, which forced him to flee to Estonia. In 1938 he completed his doctorate and moved to Zurich, Switzerland, in 1947, where he joined Bank Leu, a private bank, as a numismatist.77 At Bank Leu, Mildenberg worked with Silvia Hurter to prepare catalogues, and from 1954 to 1969 the firm partnered with Adolph Hess AG in Lucerne to organize joint coin auctions. After 1971, the bank published its own catalogues, authored by Mildenberg. In 1973 he partnered with Herbert Cahn for a joint coin auction.78 Although the expert on coins with Bank Leu, Mildenberg built up a personal collection of ancient artifacts depicting animals. The collection was published several times until its dispersal at Christie’s London in 2004 and 2005.79
Symes, Robin
1939–2023, active late 1960s–early 2000s. Robin Symes Ltd., London (1977–)
Addresses 346 Kings Road, London SW3 (by 1969); 3 Ormond Yard, Duke of York Street, St. James’s, London, SW1 (1970s–80s)
Symes, born in Oxfordshire, England, by the late 1960s was running a shop together with his then-wife Laetitia Symes, on Kings Road, London, selling Early Modern antiques.80 In 1969 they mounted what may have been his first exhibition to include ancient art—gold jewelry from the de Clercq-Boisgelin collections and Egyptian, Etruscan, and Greek works, shown alongside contemporary paintings.81 In the 1970s Symes partnered with Christo Michaelides, who provided financial support to expand the business, which began to specialize in antiquities. Symes published his first antiquities catalogue in 1971.82 In 1976 he established a Panama-based company, Xoilan Trader Inc., with his partner’s financial backing.83 The next year, Symes established his own firm, Robin Symes Ltd., in London. Symes worked closely with dealers Robert Hecht, Giacomo Medici, and Frieda Tchacos. In addition to participating in a wide array of auctions, he sold to museums and high-profile collectors like Barbara and Lawrence Fleischman, Maurice Tempelsman, Lynda and William Beierwaltes, and Shelby White and Leon Levy. Beginning in the early 1970s, Symes advertised frequently in Apollo, often with objects illustrated.84 In 1988 Symes sold the Morgantina Goddess to the Getty Museum (88.AA.76), its provenance fabricated; after a 2007 agreement with the Republic of Italy to return the statue, it remained on display at the Getty Villa until 2010.85 Following the sudden death of Michaelides in 1999, Symes tried to retain all of their shared company assets, which led to a legal dispute with Michaelides’s family. An investigation into Symes’s business dealings revealed that he had lied about the extent and value of their collection; he was found guilty of contempt in 2005. The trial also revealed that Symes stored antiquities at thirty-three locations and had connections to the illicit antiquities trade. A 2006 raid on the Michaelides property on the Greek island of Schinoussa recovered a photographic archive of more than two thousand images of nearly a thousand high-quality antiquities—all objects handled by Symes and Michaelides.86 Symes’s inventory also included works acquired at auction and on the market that might have longer collecting histories. In 2014 Italian and Swiss police jointly raided a Geneva storage unit rented by Robin Symes, and in 2016 revealed that it contained forty-five crates of antiquities, which were subsequently returned to Italy.87
Tchacos, Frieda
Active 1970s–90s, also as Frederique Tchacos-Nussberger or Nussberger-Tchacos. Galerie Uraeus, Paris (1970s–80s); Galerie Nefer, Zurich (1977–)
Addresses 24 Rue de Seine, Paris; Augustinergasse 14, Zurich, Switzerland
Born in Egypt and of Greek descent, Tchacos pursued her education in Europe, first in Geneva, then at the École du Louvre in Paris to study Egyptology. After her studies, Tchacos remained in Paris where she opened an art gallery and met dealers, including Nicolas Koutoulakis. By the mid- or late 1970s, Tchacos was the owner of Galerie Uraeus in Paris, which was active through the 1980s.88 Proficient in multiple languages, including Arabic, she built up her reputation internationally and by 1977 established Galerie Nefer in Zurich. In the early 1980s she married Werner Nussberger, a Swiss jeweler and dealer from Baden, Switzerland. In the early 1980s her gallery was described as a high-end shop offering Greek, Roman, and Luristan art with a good selection of Egyptian material.89 Galerie Nefer produced annual catalogues from 1982 to 1992 and specialized exhibition catalogues during the 1990s. Famously, in 1999 Tchacos bought the so-called Gospel of Judas manuscript that had surfaced in the 1970s, likely through illegal channels, and after failed sale attempts she ultimately arranged for the manuscript to be returned to Egypt.90 Tchacos’s name appears in the organigram, connecting her to Robert Hecht and the trade of illicit antiquities. In 2002 Italian authorities arrested her in Cyprus, and she was found guilty of handling stolen artifacts.91
Tozzi, Piero
1882–1974, active 1920s–70s. Piero Tozzi Galleries, Florence and New York
Address 137 East 57th Street, New York
Tozzi was an antiquarian, artist, restorer, professor, and art dealer with galleries in Florence and New York, which focused on Italian decorative arts, sculpture, and painting but also sold antiquities to dealers, private collectors, and museums.92 The records of the Brummer Gallery have more than a hundred and fifty ancient object cards linked to Tozzi. The Piero Tozzi archive is held by the Onassis Library for Hellenic and Roman Art at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York (see Piero Tozzi in Appendix 1, under “Dealers”).
Yeganeh Arani, Mohammad
1929–2012, active by 1954 and into 1980s, also as Mohammad Jägane; Mohammed Yegane; Manuchehr Jamali. Galerie für Griechische, Römische und Byzantinische Kunst, Frankfurt; Apollo Gallery, Frankfurt and London; also active in Stuttgart and La Mesa, California
Addresses Taunusstrasse 52,93 Bundenweg 7, and Telemannstrasse 5, 6, all in Frankfurt, Germany; Alexanderstraße 112/1, Stuttgart, Germany; 75A Ridgmount Gardens, London WC1, England
Based in Frankfurt, Yeganeh dealt primarily in antiquities. The name of his wife, Gertrud Waltraud Lück-Flender, appears on some provenance documentation. He advertised in, among others, the Jahrbuch der Hamburger Kunstsammlunge, Die Weltkunst, The Burlington Magazine, and Apollo. Between 1969 and 1986 he sold dozens of antiquities to the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, including the Herakles, which has since been returned to Türkiye, as discussed by Rose in this volume.94 Yeganeh dealt in objects from a range of cultures, including Greek, Roman, Iberian, South Italian, East Greek, Roman Syrian, and modern objects, although Persian and Iranian objects were a focus. His gallery produced a small catalogue in 1971, which includes two objects donated to the Getty in 1974 and 1983.95
Notes
-
See, for example, The International Antiques Yearbook and Antiquities Trade Gazette. ↩︎
-
Hagen, Fredrik, and Kim Ryholt. 2016. The Antiquities Trade in Egypt 1880–1930: The H. O. Lange Papers. Copenhagen: Det Kongelige Danske VidenskabernesSelskab.. ↩︎
-
See Tompkins, Arthur, ed. 2020. Provenance Research Today: Principles, Practice, Problems. London: Lund Humphries.; Chappell, Duncan, and Kenneth Polk. 2011. “Unraveling the ‘Cordata’: Just How Organized is the International Traffic in Cultural Objects?” In Crime in the Art and Antiquities World: Illegal Trafficking in Cultural Property, edited by Stefano Manacorda and Duncan Chappell, 99–113. New York: Springer.. ↩︎
-
Hoffmann, Herbert, and Herbert Adolph Cahn. 1971. Collecting Greek Antiquities. New York: C. N. Potter.. ↩︎
-
The chart roughly documents the trade networks in Italy in the early 1990s; see Brodie, Neil. 2012. “Organigram.” Trafficking Culture, August 21. https://traffickingculture.org/encyclopedia/case-studies/organigram/.. See also Watson, Peter, and Cecilia Todeschini. 2007. The Medici Conspiracy: The Illicit Journey of Looted Antiquities from Italy’s Tomb Raiders to the World’s Greatest Museums. New York: BBS Public Affairs.. ↩︎
-
To explore Getty object records linked to these individuals, search the dealer’s name on the Getty Museum Collection pages (includes deaccessioned records and works currently in the collection): https://www.getty.edu/art/collection/. ↩︎
-
Collectors’ guides include Nicholson, Felicity. 1965. Greek, Etruscan, and Roman Pottery and Small Terra-Cottas: A Brief Guide for the Small Collector, with a Note on Greek Dress. London: Cory, Adams & Mackay., Hoffmann, Herbert, and Herbert Adolph Cahn. 1971. Collecting Greek Antiquities. New York: C. N. Potter., and Ede, Charles. 1976. Collecting Antiquities: An Introductory Guide. London: J. M. Dent & Sons.; memoirs include Hecht, Robert E., and Geraldine Norman. 2014. Bob Hecht by Bob Hecht. n.p., Hoving, Thomas. 1993. Making the Mummies Dance: Inside the Metropolitan Museum of Art. New York: Schuster and Schuster., McNall, Bruce, and Michael D’Antonio. 2003. Fun While It Lasted: My Rise and Fall in the Land of Fame and Fortune. New York: Hyperion., and Boardman, John, ed. 2017. Elie Borowski: Founder of the Bible Lands Museum, Jerusalem. Jerusalem: Bible Lands Museum.. ↩︎
-
Watson, Peter, and Cecilia Todeschini. 2007. The Medici Conspiracy: The Illicit Journey of Looted Antiquities from Italy’s Tomb Raiders to the World’s Greatest Museums. New York: BBS Public Affairs.. ↩︎
-
Lapatin, Kenneth. 2000. “Proof? The Case of the Getty Kouros.” Source: Notes in the History of Art 20, no. 1: 43–53. http://www.jstor.org/stable/23206964.. ↩︎
-
For example, an Athenian red-figure pelike, returned to Italy in 2006 (Museum of Fine Arts, Boston 1979.40) and an Etruscan black-figure kalpis, returned to Italy in 2013 (Toledo, Museum of Arts, 82.134, Brodie, Neil. 2014. “Toledo Museum of Art Return to Italy (2013).” Trafficking Culture, June 5. https://traffickingculture.org/encyclopedia/case-studies/toledo-museum-of-art-return-to-italy-2013/. and Toledo Museum of Art. “Ancient Etruscan Kalpis.” Archived November 19, 2023, at the Wayback Machine. https://web.archive.org/web/20220328012823/https:/www.toledomuseum.org/art/provenance-and-repatriation/ancient-etruscan-kalpis.). ↩︎
-
Watson, Peter, and Cecilia Todeschini. 2007. The Medici Conspiracy: The Illicit Journey of Looted Antiquities from Italy’s Tomb Raiders to the World’s Greatest Museums. New York: BBS Public Affairs.. ↩︎
-
Watson, Peter, and Cecilia Todeschini. 2007. The Medici Conspiracy: The Illicit Journey of Looted Antiquities from Italy’s Tomb Raiders to the World’s Greatest Museums. New York: BBS Public Affairs.. ↩︎
-
Fitz-Gibbon, Kate. 2017. “Due Diligence: Access Denied to Data on Stolen Art. Keeping Information Secret Harms Museums and Marketplace.” Cultural Property News. July 10. https://culturalpropertynews.org/due-diligence-access-to-databases-of-stolen-antiquities-denied/.. ↩︎
-
Watson, Peter, and Cecilia Todeschini. 2007. The Medici Conspiracy: The Illicit Journey of Looted Antiquities from Italy’s Tomb Raiders to the World’s Greatest Museums. New York: BBS Public Affairs.. ↩︎
-
The addresses of the Basel and Paris galleries are given in Hoffmann, Herbert, and Herbert Adolph Cahn. 1971. Collecting Greek Antiquities. New York: C. N. Potter.; in some sources, the Paris gallery is called Archéologie Classique et du Proche-Orient. ↩︎
-
The relation of Nina Borowski to Elie Borowski is unconfirmed, but both have advertisements with the 40 Rue du Bac, Paris, address. Nina Borowski produced a few catalogues; additional references to art fair exhibitions for the Paris gallery are found in Artis and Die Weltkunst. ↩︎
-
On the exhibitions, see Pantazzi, Michael. 1981. Echoes from Roman Villas: Pompeian Mural Paintings from the Collection of Dr. Elie Borowski. Exhibition catalogue. Ottawa: National Gallery of Canada., Leipen, Neda, Paul Denis, J. Robert Guy, and Arthur Trendall. 1984. Glimpses of Excellence: A Selection of Greek Vases and Bronzes from the Elie Borowski Collection. Exhibition catalogue. Toronto: Royal Ontario Museum., and Borowski, Elie. 2001. Glories of Ancient Greece: Vases and Jewelry from the Borowski Collection. Jerusalem: Bible Lands Museum.; on the auctions: see Christie’s. 2000. Ancient Greek Vases Formerly in the Private Collection of Dr. Elie Borowski. June 12, 2000, auction catalogue. New York: Christie’s.; objects sold and donated to museums, including the Getty Museum, Royal Ontario Museum, Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, and others; for a discussion of the likely illicit origins of the Arslan Tash ivories that Barowski sold, see Fontan, Elisabeth. 2014. “Ivories of Arslan Tash.” In Assyria to Iberia: At the Dawn of the Classical Age, exhibition catalogue, edited by Joan Aruz, Sarah B. Graff, and Yelena Rakic, 152–56. New York: Metropolitan Museum of Art.. ↩︎
-
Mentioned in Robert Hecht’s memoir as a client of Giacomo Medici; Hecht, Robert E., and Geraldine Norman. 2014. Bob Hecht by Bob Hecht. n.p.. ↩︎
-
Boardman, John, ed. 2017. Elie Borowski: Founder of the Bible Lands Museum, Jerusalem. Jerusalem: Bible Lands Museum.; for The Bible Lands Museum Jerusalem, see https://www.blmj.org/en/about/. ↩︎
-
Their New York gallery changed locations frequently: 19 West 52nd Street; 27, 30, 43, 53, and 55 East 57th Street; 110 East 58th Street, 11 East 68th Street, and 383 Park Avenue. ↩︎
-
The antiquities were sold in the third sale; Parke-Bernet Galleries. 1949. The Notable Art Collection Belonging to the Estate of the Late Joseph Brummer, Part III: Classical and Medieval Stone Sculptures. June 8, 1949, auction catalogue. New York: Parke-Bernet Galleries.. ↩︎
-
Sotheby’s. 1964. The Ernest Brummer Collection of Egyptian and Near Eastern Antiquities and Works of Art. November 16–17, 1964, auction catalogue. London: Sotheby’s.; Galerie Koller. 1979. The Ernest Brummer Collection, Medieval, Renaissance, and Baroque Art: Auction Sale from the 16th to 19th October 1979 at the Grand Hotel Dolder. Zurich: Galerie Koller and Spink & Son.. ↩︎
-
The digitized archive can be accessed at The Met, “The Brummer Gallery Records,” Digital Collections from The Metropolitan Museum of Art Libraries, http://libmma.contentdm.oclc.org/cdm/landingpage/collection/p16028coll9. ↩︎
-
The Metropolitan Museum held a conference on the Brummer Galleries, October 13–14, 2017; also see Biro, Yaëlle, Christine E. Brennan, and Christel H. Force, eds. 2023. The Brummer Galleries, Paris and New York: Defining Taste from Antiquities to the Avant-Garde. Studies in the History of Collecting & Art Markets 17. Leiden: Brill.. ↩︎
-
Hoffmann, Herbert, and Herbert Adolph Cahn. 1971. Collecting Greek Antiquities. New York: C. N. Potter.. ↩︎
-
See Faber-Castell, Christian van. 1983. “Zwischen Ägypten und Rom: Der Antikenhandel in der Schweiz.” Die Weltkunst 53, January–March: 554–58.. ↩︎
-
Vase fragments from Cahn’s collection are often labeled with their inventory number in red ink, as discussed in Chapter 2 in the section “Examining the Object”. For publications of the fragments: Schmidt, Margot. 1991. Der zerbrochene Krug: Vasenfragmente klassischer Zeit aus Athen und Grossgriechenland; Sammlung H.A. Cahn: Ausstellung im Antikenmuseum Basel und Sammlung Ludwig (13. Juni-31. Oktober 1991). Exhibition catalogue. Basel: Gissler.; Cahn, Herbert Adolph, and Bettina Kreuzer. 1993. Griechische Vasenfragmente der Sammlung Herbert A. Cahn, Basel. Hannover: Kestner-Museum.; Cambitoglou, Alexander, Jacques Chamay, and Brenno Bottini. 1997. Céramique de Grande Grèce: La collection de fragments Herbert A. Cahn. Zürich: Akanthus.. Other works from his collection were sold at auction in 2002; see Cahn, Jean David. 2002. Kunstwerke der Antike. October 18, 2002, auction catalogue. Basel: Jean David Cahn.. ↩︎
-
Cahn. n.d. “Provenance.” Galerie Cahn. https://cahn.ch/Provenance. ↩︎
-
Hecht, Robert E., and Geraldine Norman. 2014. Bob Hecht by Bob Hecht. n.p.. In 1976, fifteen years after the charges were first brought, Cahn was found guilty of possessing illicit antiquities; these were the only charges ever brought against Cahn; Watson, Peter, and Cecilia Todeschini. 2007. The Medici Conspiracy: The Illicit Journey of Looted Antiquities from Italy’s Tomb Raiders to the World’s Greatest Museums. New York: BBS Public Affairs.. ↩︎
-
Wolfson, Brian. 2002. “Charles Ede: Publisher Who Made Quality Work Available to Everyman.” Guardian, June 12. https://www.theguardian.com/news/2002/jun/12/guardianobituaries.booksobituaries.. ↩︎
-
The Folio Society even published a guide to collecting: Nicholson, Felicity. 1965. Greek, Etruscan, and Roman Pottery and Small Terra-Cottas: A Brief Guide for the Small Collector, with a Note on Greek Dress. London: Cory, Adams & Mackay.. ↩︎
-
Ede, Charles. 1976. Collecting Antiquities: An Introductory Guide. London: J. M. Dent & Sons.. ↩︎
-
On the Collector’s Cabinet, see Reed, J. D. 1975. “Shopwalk: Mother Earth for Sale—Only $4.50 (Plus Tax), Including a Lucite Stand.” Sports Illustrated, June 16: 6. https://archive.org/details/Sports-Illustrated-1975-06-16/page/n7/mode/2up.. ↩︎
-
Other than a home page noting the closure of the gallery, the Royal-Athena website is no longer active, but information including a description of the firm and other pages can still be accessed through archived webpages: https://web.archive.org/web/20200224195611/http://royalathena.com/PAGES/intropages/introduction.html. ↩︎
-
On the closure and the transfer of stock, see the notice on the current website home page: http://www.royalathena.com/. ↩︎
-
André Emmerich Gallery, Masterpieces of Greek Vase Painting: 7th to 5th century B.C., April–March 1964, exh. cat. (New York: André Emmerich Gallery, 1964); André Emmerich Gallery, Art of the Ancients: Greek, Etruscans and Romans, February 7–March 13, 1968 (New York: André Emmerich Gallery, 1968); André Emmerich Gallery, Art of Ancient Italy, exh. cat. (New York: André Emmerich Gallery, 1970). ↩︎
-
https://www.aaa.si.edu/collections/andr-emmerich-gallery-records-and-andr-emmerich-papers-6275. ↩︎
-
Simon, Erika. 1995. “Giorgio Fallani und das Martin-von-Wagner-Museum.” Antike Welt 26, no. 5: 404–5.; Hoffmann, Herbert, and Herbert Adolph Cahn. 1971. Collecting Greek Antiquities. New York: C. N. Potter.. ↩︎
-
For a brief history of the Fallani family: Fallani, Carlo-Maria, Erika Simon, and Harula Economopoulos. 1997. Dei e uomini. Rome: Fallani.. ↩︎
-
Hecht, Robert E., and Geraldine Norman. 2014. Bob Hecht by Bob Hecht. n.p. (George Allen). ↩︎
-
Hecht established Hesperia Art in New York, where it was operated by Vladimir Clain-Stefanelli for a few years (early 1950s), until it was converted into a primarily mail-order business. The business name was revived in 1990 as Hesperia Arts Auction Ltd. to sell Hecht and McNall’s Summa Gallery stock. George Allen (1918–1997), a Haverford college friend of Hecht’s, ran his father’s rare books store, William H. Allen, Bookseller, 2031 Walnut Street, Philadelphia, from 1940 until his death, and ran Hesperia Art with Hecht from 1957 until the early 1970s. Allen served as Hecht’s agent in the sale of the “Trojan Gold” to the University of Pennsylvania Museum in 1966; see Rose, C. Brian. 2017. “Beyond the UNESCO Convention: The Case of the Troy Gold in the Penn Museum.” Journal of Eastern Mediterranean Archaeology and Heritage Studies 5, no. 1: 87–91. and in this volume. ↩︎
-
https://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/255353. ↩︎
-
Rosen and Hecht established Atlantis Antiquities Ltd. in 1984, with Andrea Hecht serving as the director by 1988, Reif, Rita. 1988. “Archaic Smiles Have Persisted for 2,000 Years.” New York Times, June 19. https://www.nytimes.com/1988/06/19/arts/archaic-smiles-have-persisted-for-2000-years.html.. They published several sales catalogues, including ARS and TEXHN: Art and Craft of the Graeco-Roman World from 450 B.C. to 600 A.D. (1989) and Robert Hecht, Greek and Roman Art (1990). ↩︎
-
On museums to which Hecht sold material: Hecht, Robert E., and Geraldine Norman. 2014. Bob Hecht by Bob Hecht. n.p.; Watson, Peter, and Cecilia Todeschini. 2007. The Medici Conspiracy: The Illicit Journey of Looted Antiquities from Italy’s Tomb Raiders to the World’s Greatest Museums. New York: BBS Public Affairs.. ↩︎
-
Hagen, Fredrik, and Kim Ryholt. 2016. The Antiquities Trade in Egypt 1880–1930: The H. O. Lange Papers. Copenhagen: Det Kongelige Danske VidenskabernesSelskab.. ↩︎
-
Dikran Kelekian, The Kelekian Collection of Persian and Analogous Potteries, 1885–1910 (Paris: H. Clarke, 1910), https://archive.org/details/kelekiancollect00kele/mode/2up; Dikran Kelekian, Additional Documents of Coptic Art: In the Collection of Dikran G. Kelekian, Inc. (New York: Delphic Press, 1941). ↩︎
-
For more on Kelekian’s connections to the Metropolitan Museum, see The Met, “Buried Finds: Textile Collectors in Egypt,” 2012, https://www.metmuseum.org/exhibitions/listings/2012/buried-finds. ↩︎
-
The Kelekian Archive (Onassis Library for Hellenic and Roman Art, Department of Greek and Roman Art, Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York) contains invoices, correspondence, ledgers and shipment inventories, catalogues, and photographs and can be consulted on site. Also see deCamargo, Luiza. 2012. “Content and Character: Dikran Kelekian and Eastern Decorative Arts Objects in America.” MA thesis, Smithsonian Associates and the Corcoran College of Art and Design. https://scholarspace.library.gwu.edu/etd/5712m675f.. For additional archives containing Kelekian’s correspondence, see “Archives Directory for the History of Collecting in America,” The Frick Collection, https://research.frick.org/directory/detail/946. ↩︎
-
United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, Oral history interview with Susanne K. Bennet, daughter of John Jacob Klejman, March 22, 2012, transcript; accession no. RG-50.106.0195, https://collections.ushmm.org/oh_findingaids/RG-50.106.0195_trs_en.pdf. ↩︎
-
Canaday, John. 1973. “Met Proud of a Rare Greek Pitcher.” New York Times, February 26. https://www.nytimes.com/1973/02/26/archives/met-proud-of-a-rare-greek-pitcher-calls-venders-traders-left-native.html.. ↩︎
-
Waxman, Sharon. 2008. Loot: The Battle over Stolen Treasures of the Ancient World. New York: Times Books.. ↩︎
-
Hecht, Robert E., and Geraldine Norman. 2014. Bob Hecht by Bob Hecht. n.p.. ↩︎
-
New York Times. 1984. “Mathias Komor Dies, Expert on Antiquities.” July 5, obituaries. https://www.nytimes.com/1984/07/05/obituaries/no-headline-045287.html.; additional biographical details from Ogbechie, Sylvester Okwunodu. 2019. “Mathias Komor and the Market for African Art in New York.” In Acquiring Cultures: Histories of World Art on Western Markets, edited by Bénédicte Savoy, Charlotte Guichard, and Christine Howald, 167–88. Boston: De Gruyter.. ↩︎
-
Mathias Komor Photographic Archive, 1934–1978, The Getty Research Institute, Los Angeles, accession no. 89.P.5, http://hdl.handle.net/10020/cifa89p5. Additional correspondence archives are held by other institutions, some of which include: University of Missouri, Museum of Art and Archaeology, Administrative Records, Box 5 FF 46, Mathias Komor: New York, 1960–1981; Philadelphia Museum of Art archives, Henry P. McIlhenny Papers: V. Art collection: B. Objects by genre, Box 77, Folder 2: Ceramics. Mathias Komor [firm]. 1946–1950; Cleveland Museum of Art, Ingalls Library and Museum Archives, Records of the Director’s Office: William Mathewson Milliken, 1930–1958, Series 1, Box 25, folder 2: Komor, Mathias, 1946–1957. ↩︎
-
For an example of a Louis de Clercq and Henri de Boisgelin provenance, see Sotheby’s. 2018. Ancient Sculpture & Works of Art. July 3, 2018, auction catalogue. London: Sotheby’s., lot 16. ↩︎
-
Getz-Gentle, Pat. 2008. “The Keros Hoard Revisited.” American Journal of Archaeology 112, no. 2: 299–305.. ↩︎
-
Millon et Associés. 2016. Archéologie et Préhistoire. December 13, 2016, Hotel Drouot, auction catalogue. Paris: Millon.; Karagelou, Natasha. 2008. Steris: Works from the Koutoulakis Collection. Athens: Mouseio Benakē.. ↩︎
-
Gill, David W. J. 2019. “Context Matters: Nicolas Koutoulakis, the Antiquities Market and Due Diligence.” Journal of Art Crime 22: 71–78.; also see, on the Getty return of an ancient bronze head to Türkiye, 71.AB.458 (https://www.getty.edu/art/collection/object/103SV3): J. Paul Getty Trust. 2024. “Getty Returns Ancient Bronze Head to Türkiye.” Getty News and Stories. April 24. https://www.getty.edu/news/getty-returns-ancient-bronze-head-to-turkiye/.. ↩︎
-
Located at Rue Hôtel-de-Ville 9, Geneva; Krosney, Herbert. 2006. The Lost Gospel: The Quest for the Gospel of Judas Iscariot. Washington, DC: National Geographic Society.. ↩︎
-
At the time of writing, the following resources list Koutoulakis in their finding aids: Brooklyn Museum, New York, “Guide to the Records of the Department of Egyptian, Classical, and Ancient Near Eastern Art, 1890s–2002” (2013), https://d1lfxha3ugu3d4.cloudfront.net/archives/ECANEA_2013.pdf; Museum of Modern Art, New York, Paul Rosenberg Archives, https://www.moma.org/research/archives/finding-aids/PaulRosenbergf, II.E.12, K Miscellaneous 1947–1949, Koutoulakis, N. ↩︎
-
Joel Malter, of Joel L. Malter & Co. in Encino, was the primary ancient coin dealer in Los Angeles in the 1960s; on Malter, see Kammerer, Craig. 2004. “Reminisces of the Early Days of Coin Auctions, Auction Catalogues, Numismatic Publications and the NBS.” The Asylum: Quarterly Journal of the Numismatic Bibliomania Society (Fall): 362–66.. ↩︎
-
McNall, Bruce, and Michael D’Antonio. 2003. Fun While It Lasted: My Rise and Fall in the Land of Fame and Fortune. New York: Hyperion.. ↩︎
-
McNall, Bruce, and Michael D’Antonio. 2003. Fun While It Lasted: My Rise and Fall in the Land of Fame and Fortune. New York: Hyperion., chapter 3. ↩︎
-
Sotheby’s New York sold the Hunt collection in several auctions: June 19, 1990; June 21–22, 1990; December 4, 1990; June 19–20, 1991. ↩︎
-
Solis-Cohen, Lita. 1990. “Auction House Specializes in Antiquities.” Baltimore Sun. November 11. https://www.baltimoresun.com/1990/11/11/auction-house-specializes-in-antiquities/.; and see the Hecht biography above. ↩︎
-
For a detailed discussion of Medici’s family and childhood, see Watson, Peter, and Cecilia Todeschini. 2007. The Medici Conspiracy: The Illicit Journey of Looted Antiquities from Italy’s Tomb Raiders to the World’s Greatest Museums. New York: BBS Public Affairs.; Silver, Vernon. 2009. The Lost Chalice: The Epic Hunt for a Priceless Masterpiece. New York: Harper Collins.; Hecht, Robert E., and Geraldine Norman. 2014. Bob Hecht by Bob Hecht. n.p.. ↩︎
-
The pharmacist Pesciotti (first name Cima or Angelo) had official permission to build his collection since it was to be donated to the state; Silver, Vernon. 2009. The Lost Chalice: The Epic Hunt for a Priceless Masterpiece. New York: Harper Collins.. According to Hecht’s memoir, Medici acquired these antiquities from “clandestine diggers” in Central Italy and these looted objects either stayed in the Pesciotti collection, now in the National Etruscan Museum (Villa Giulia) in Rome, or were sold on the market through Herbert Cahn; Hecht, Robert E., and Geraldine Norman. 2014. Bob Hecht by Bob Hecht. n.p.. ↩︎
-
Hecht, Robert E., and Geraldine Norman. 2014. Bob Hecht by Bob Hecht. n.p.. ↩︎
-
Watson, Peter, and Cecilia Todeschini. 2007. The Medici Conspiracy: The Illicit Journey of Looted Antiquities from Italy’s Tomb Raiders to the World’s Greatest Museums. New York: BBS Public Affairs.. ↩︎
-
Watson, Peter, and Cecilia Todeschini. 2007. The Medici Conspiracy: The Illicit Journey of Looted Antiquities from Italy’s Tomb Raiders to the World’s Greatest Museums. New York: BBS Public Affairs.; Silver, Vernon. 2009. The Lost Chalice: The Epic Hunt for a Priceless Masterpiece. New York: Harper Collins.. ↩︎
-
Henri Albert Jacques managed Edition Services on behalf of Medici; Jacques also managed Xoilan Trader Inc. on behalf of Robin Symes. Other fronts include Serge Vilbert, “Guido” (Medici’s father’s name), and the company Tecafin Fiduciare. See Watson, Peter, and Cecilia Todeschini. 2007. The Medici Conspiracy: The Illicit Journey of Looted Antiquities from Italy’s Tomb Raiders to the World’s Greatest Museums. New York: BBS Public Affairs.. ↩︎
-
The “Zbinden collection” was used as a front with Sotheby’s that was linked to Christian Boursaud; Watson, Peter, and Cecilia Todeschini. 2007. The Medici Conspiracy: The Illicit Journey of Looted Antiquities from Italy’s Tomb Raiders to the World’s Greatest Museums. New York: BBS Public Affairs.. ↩︎
-
For a discussion of some objects identified from the archive, see Gill, David, and Christos Tsirogiannis. 2016. “Polaroids from the Medici Dossier: Continued Sightings on the Market.” In Art Crime: Terrorists, Tomb Raiders, Forgers and Thieves, edited by Noah Charney, 229–39. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.; and for a summary, see Brodie, Neil. 2023. “Giacomo Medici.” Trafficking Culture, April 11. https://traffickingculture.org/encyclopedia/case-studies/giacomo-medici/., https://traffickingculture.org/encyclopedia/case-studies/giacomo-medici/ and Silver, Vernon. 2009. The Lost Chalice: The Epic Hunt for a Priceless Masterpiece. New York: Harper Collins.. ↩︎
-
See “Statement of Facts, In the Matter of A Grand Jury Investigation Into a Private New York Antiquities Collector (Michael Steinhardt), Dec. 6, 2021”: https://images.law.com/contrib/content/uploads/documents/292/102693/2021-12-06-Steinhardt-Statement-of-Facts-w-Attachments-Filed.pdf. ↩︎
-
See the current Merrin Gallery website at https://merringallery.com/. ↩︎
-
Hoffmann, Herbert, and Herbert Adolph Cahn. 1971. Collecting Greek Antiquities. New York: C. N. Potter.. ↩︎
-
“Leo Mildenberg,” Coins Weekly, October 14, 2009, https://new.coinsweekly.com/nations/leo-mildenberg-2/. ↩︎
-
Bank Leu and Münzen und Medaillen, Griechische Münzen aus der Sammlung eines Kunstfreundes, sales cat., May 28, 1974, Zurich. ↩︎
-
J. Biers, ed., A Peaceable Kingdom: Animals in Ancient Art from the Leo Mildenberg Collection, part VI, auction cat., Christie’s London, October 26–27, 2004, and April 20, 2005 (Mainz: von Zabern, 2004). ↩︎
-
The earliest references to Robin Symes’s Kings Road shop are from 1967 and describe it as offering “Medieval and renaissance works of art, wood sculptures, early 17th century furniture”; The 1967–8 International Antiques Yearbook, ed. Philip Wilson (London: Studio Vista, 1967) 289. ↩︎
-
“The Inside Page,” Daily Mirror, February 5, 1969, 11. ↩︎
-
Symes sold antiquities to the British Museum as early as 1969 (a group of five Cycladic objects, 1969,1001.1–5, and a silver medallion, 1969,0403.1); the 1971 catalogue includes thirty-three objects, including Cycladic figures, Greek and Roman bronzes, Roman sculpture, Egyptian panel portraits and sculpture, and jewelry. Robin Symes, Ancient Art, dealer cat. (London: n.p., 1971). ↩︎
-
Xoilan Trader Inc. shared a Geneva administrative address (7 Avenue Krieg) with Medici’s Editions Services; both were managed by Henri Albert Jacques. Xoilan was owned by Alexander Michaelides, a relative of Christo Michaelides. Symes claimed Xoilan was for his personal collection; Watson, Peter, and Cecilia Todeschini. 2007. The Medici Conspiracy: The Illicit Journey of Looted Antiquities from Italy’s Tomb Raiders to the World’s Greatest Museums. New York: BBS Public Affairs., note 67. ↩︎
-
Symes advertised in Apollo between 1969 and 1999. ↩︎
-
88.AA.76 (https://www.getty.edu/art/collection/object/1HC1T7); Brodie, Neil. 2012. “Getty Aphrodite.” Trafficking Culture, August 21. http://traffickingculture.org/encyclopedia/case-studies/1059/.; Rose, in this volume; Felch, Jason, and Ralph Frammolino, 2011. Chasing Aphrodite: The Hunt for Looted Antiquities at the World’s Richest Museum. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt.. ↩︎
-
Watson, Peter, and Cecilia Todeschini. 2007. The Medici Conspiracy: The Illicit Journey of Looted Antiquities from Italy’s Tomb Raiders to the World’s Greatest Museums. New York: BBS Public Affairs.. With the exception of four Polaroid photographs, the Schinoussa photo archive’s images are shot by professional photographers and have studio stamps on the backs, indicating locations that include Basel, Switzerland; Kingston-upon-Thames, England; Bond Street, London; and Madison Avenue, New York. ↩︎
-
“Stolen Artefacts Stashed by British Art Dealer Are Returned to Italy,” The Guardian, March 22, 2016, https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/mar/22/stolen-artefacts-stashed-british-art-dealer-returned-italy. For further discussion of Symes’s collection, see Swains, Howard. 2017. “London’s Loot: The Legacy of Robin Symes.” Medium, September 24. https://howardswains.medium.com/robin-symes-looted-antiquities-9e4dc232059d.. ↩︎
-
See The International Antiques Yearbook 1976, and the International Art and Antiques Yearbook 1979–80; the Brooklyn Museum has archival material with Tchacos as a representative of both Galerie Uraeus and Galerie Nefer from 1971 to 1983; https://archives.brooklynmuseum.org/repositories/2/archival_objects/18986. ↩︎
-
Faber-Castell, Christian van. 1983. “Zwischen Ägypten und Rom: Der Antikenhandel in der Schweiz.” Die Weltkunst 53, January–March: 554–58.. ↩︎
-
For a good review, see Brodie, Neil. 2006. “The Lost, Found, Lost Again and Found Again Gospel of Judas.” Culture without Context 19. https://traffickingculture.org/publications/brodie-n-2006-the-lost-found-lost-again-and-found-again-gospel-of-judas-culture-without-context-19-17-27/.. ↩︎
-
Watson, Peter, and Cecilia Todeschini. 2007. The Medici Conspiracy: The Illicit Journey of Looted Antiquities from Italy’s Tomb Raiders to the World’s Greatest Museums. New York: BBS Public Affairs.. ↩︎
-
“Tozzi, Piero,” in “Archives Directory for the History of Collecting in America,” The Frick Collection, https://research.frick.org/directory/detail/3027. ↩︎
-
Hoffmann, Herbert, and Herbert Adolph Cahn. 1971. Collecting Greek Antiquities. New York: C. N. Potter.. ↩︎
-
MFA Boston 1981.783 (https://collections.mfa.org/objects/149765/weary-herakles-herakles-farnese-type); Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, “Ownership Resolutions: 2011–Weary Herakles” https://www.mfa.org/collections/provenance/antiquities-and-archeological-material; Victoria Reed, “Due Diligence, Provenance Research, and the Acquisition Process at the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston,” DePaul Journal of Art, Technology and Intellectual Property Law, 23(2) (Spring 2013). https://via.library.depaul.edu/jatip/vol23/iss2/4. ↩︎
-
74.AA.37 (https://www.getty.edu/art/collection/object/103SZH) and 83.AE.320 (https://www.getty.edu/art/collection/object/103VGY) were published in Erwin Bielefeld, Kunstwerke der Antike, dealer cat. (Frankfurt: Galerie für griechische, römische und byzantinische Kunst, 1971). ↩︎