Note: To protect the privacy of our members, e-mail addresses have been removed from the archived messages. As a result, some links may be broken.
Perspective...CAN anyone be RIGHT OR WRONG? CAN this (art, maybe art, non
art) notion be UNIVERSAL?...isn't right or wrong (art, maybe art, non art)
all relative. Some cultures/societies don't even have a word for art.
>>"Art-Not art-Maybe art" seems cool. I think you invent an interesting term
>>"Maybeart". How about something like "Maybenotart", "Shouldbeart", Can a
>>thing be simultaneously "art" and "nonart", (or even "maybeart"?
>>Leung Tsz Kwong
>Yes, according to my students, a thing *can* be "art and not art" at the
>same time. It all depends on the thoughts of the viewer. Of course then
>we get into the discussion of absolutes - can something be art in and of
>itself or does it take interaction with a viewer to make it art? Exactly
>what is it that makes a thing art? We actually had a half hour debate with
>5th graders about how a four-sided cheese grater was art because even tho'
>it was made by machines, it was designed by a person, and it had pattern,
>texture and form!!! Then there are always the holdouts that say *nothing*
>that has a function can be art!! I must admit, I love hearing their
>thoughts about the subject!!