One more reason I seem to remember for a decline in participation was the
highly unpleasant "troll" incident a few summers back; it seems to me we
lost a few members at that time who didn't return.
And as others have said, I want to say "thanks" to all of you for great
ideas, and just for the feeling of community I've had on this listserve!
-Lydia in Toledo
----- Original Message -----
From: "Peggy Woolsey" <firstname.lastname@example.org>
To: "TeacherArtExchange Discussion Group"
Sent: Thursday, October 09, 2008 6:09 PM
Subject: Re: [teacherartexchange] Participation in TeacherArtExchange
> Thanks Ann for this contribution.
> I might add another possible cause of list serve decline, at least for
> some: a US centered focus. Of course an American focus makes sense since
> most of the list servers are Americans, but sometimes I don't think we
> all take into account the international nature of this list. I sometimes
> wonder if my input often goes unacknowledged because I am reading and
> thinking differently, in my case, Canadian, or if it is just me and what
> I have to say. We do a good deal of bantering around ideas, even
> challenges here, but that kind of discussion seems to be offensive to
> some. This is a hard thing to gauge. I have learned so much from this
> list and my hard drive is full of ideas from many years of participation.
> On 9-Oct-08, at 11:25 AM, Ann Heineman wrote:
>> Hello KJ,
>> I have been a member of the list for over ten years and I have noticed
>> the same decrease in activity that you mention. Here are my thoughts on
>> its causes:
>> 1. Technology glitches in the list serve program, i.e. periods of long
>> term "down time," problems with sign-up access, access to the archives,
>> threats that Getty would be shutting down the program, etc. In the wake
>> of these many problems, many members over the years have left to join
>> another list. We have lost many wonderful and valuable educators and
>> friends of art.
>> 2. Extreme nastiness in the form of put-downs shown by some members to
>> individuals, both written publicly on the list and/or to the member's
>> personal e-mail. As a recipient of one of these "blasts," I can attest
>> to the sting of rejection and humiliation they create.
>> 3. Lack of list etiquette--those on digest format have written
>> extensively on this topic recently. There have been other instances over
>> the years where members don't understand or want to follow the rules of
>> communicating on a list.
>> 4. Unbalance of the "takers" and the "givers." The "takers" are winning.
>> When the "givers" contribute, little acknowledgment or appreciation is
>> 5. Simple demographics: there are members of the list from early times
>> who have dropped out due to health issues, retirement, moves to new
>> careers. New educators from a younger generation are not joining.
>> 6. Our national economy is not strong and education is one of the many
>> casualties. The visual arts take the hit first.
>> I thank the many members who continue to make this list a unique
>> family for art educators and have stayed throughout all the upheavals
>> over the years!
>> Ann-on-y-mouse in Columbus
>> Art teacher, K-5, retired 6 years
>> On Oct 9, 2008, at 3:55 AM, K J wrote:
>>> Hi all,
>>> I am an Australian student studying online communities and I was
>>> wondering if I could get some help from the members of this community.
>>> Posts peaked at over 1600 a month in year 2000 and have since then
>>> dwindled to less than 200 per month, the lowest since creation. Why is
>>> this? Is it the listserv format? Or other reasons?
>>> Are there any other problems (technical, social, pedagogical etc) with
>>> being a member of this community?
>>> What do you perceive as being the greatest benefit to being a member?
>>> thank you for taking the time to respond. If you would like to reply
>>> privately, I have set up an email account for this purpose:
>>> To unsubscribe go to
>>> http://www.getty.edu/education/teacherartexchange/unsubscribe.html >>
>> To unsubscribe go tohttp://www.getty.edu/education/ >> teacherartexchange/unsubscribe.html
> To unsubscribe go to
> http://www.getty.edu/education/teacherartexchange/unsubscribe.html >