I'm with you, Woody--I had the same experience in a watercolor workshop I
was taking--the instructor worked on my painting---it ended up looking like
one of his paintings--it was no longer my piece. I have just always felt it
was disrespectful to work on anyone else's artwork--whether I was teaching
adult watercolor classes or the elementary classes I now have. I will
sometimes show how to do things on a separate sheet--but never on a
student's paper. I guess an exception would be clay pieces--where I will do
a little mending on a piece so it doesn't break--just enough to do the job,
but not destroy the integrity of the piece.
> We had a professional artist do a watercolor workshop here in
> His critique method was to paint on students work to show how to improve
> the work. I spoke up and said, being an old art teacher I personally had
> problem with that. So he only talked about suggested changes on mine. No
> one else
> in the workshop seemed to mind his methods. Maybe it's just me or my
> background ?