Note: To protect the privacy of our members, e-mail addresses have been removed from the archived messages. As a result, some links may be broken.

Find Lesson Plans on! GettyGames

RE: [teacherartexchange] Touching up Elementary Projects??


From: Melissa Woodland (melissawoodland_at_TeacherArtExchange)
Date: Wed Oct 25 2006 - 14:25:02 PDT

I had a professor in college who would DRAW on our canvas to illustrate what
was wrong and it was very annoying. There was an older woman in the class
and toward the end of the semester she actually slapped his hand as you
would a child.

Personally I don't draw on my students' papers. What I will do, is draw on a
piece of scrap paper or (as I have done this past week with perspective
drawings) use tracing paper so they can see their lines underneath. Part of
my reasoning which I share with the students is that I already passed the
class, they need to prove THEY can do it and part of the reason is that I
might suggest something, but as the artist they can choose NOT to take my
advice. It's always up to them. So no, Woody - it's not just you!

Melissa w from pennsylvania

-----Original Message-----
From: Woody Duncan []

On Oct 24, 2006, at 6:00 PM, Julie Jacobusse wrote:

> I have heard about elementary art teachers that fix/touch up student
> projects by having students complete in B&W and use the copier to
> enhance/fix projects. Then give back to students to color/paint them
> later. This was for an art show project-but I am not sure how I feel
> about this...what do all of you think? I think the students should
> learn how to draw/do things and that not every projects that students
> do will be awesome-there are special ed
> students More recently I painted over projects that had major
> mess-ups and the next time they came in asked them to fix/touch it up
> just for the sake of time element-its hard to talk them through
> fix-ups when you have a whole group to keep an eye on. Maybe I should
> have not done that either-but since it is elementary-felt it was
> ok-but middle and high schoolers would get upset I am sure.
> Thanks-Julie Jacobusse from Michigan now in georgia :)

I would "never" mark on a students work period, let alone fix/touch up a
students art.
I have taken students drawings and copied them onto various types of paper
(using a copy machine) so they could have multiple drawings to paint on.
But, it was completely their work. When I have suggestions to make or want
to demonstrate a technique I use a separate sheet of paper.

We had a professional artist do a watercolor workshop here in Albuquerque.
His critique method was to paint on students work to show how to improve the
work. I spoke up and said, being an old art teacher I personally had a
problem with that. So he only talked about suggested changes on mine.
No one else
in the workshop seemed to mind his methods. Maybe it's just me or my
background ?

Woody, Retired in Albuquerque

35 Quality Middle School Art Lessons
in powerpoint format, on one CD $17 (includes shipping)
Ordering Address: PO Box 91703
Albuquerque, NM 87199-1703

"The function of the overwhelming majority of your artwork is simply to
teach you how to make the small fraction
of your artwork that soars." from: "Art & Fear"

Woody's Watercolor Portfolio:
Newest Fantastic Triplet Pics:
My newest watercolors:

To unsubscribe go to
To unsubscribe go to