Note: To protect the privacy of our members, e-mail addresses have been removed from the archived messages. As a result, some links may be broken.

Find Lesson Plans on! GettyGames

Re: [teacherartexchange] Was the Kindergarten teacher out of line?


From: M. Austin (whest177_at_TeacherArtExchange)
Date: Sat Oct 22 2005 - 12:32:15 PDT

Personally, I would have been extremely angry that the teacher altered my
project, because she insinuated that the projects were not "good enough"
when they left your room. If I were you I would type up the learning
objectives of the lesson, explaining exactly what the children learned, and
if you haven't done so already, introduce yourself in a short blurb and talk
about how children's art is important in it's own right and that you don't
believe in using pre-made items as this detracts from their wonderful
projects. Attach this to the back of the projects before you send them home.
I would then pull her aside and explain what the notes on the back were for,
explaining that "as the classroom teacher, if parents have questions they
might contact her first and you don't want to catch her unawares." I always
try to play the subtle card first, and then if she alters your projects
again I would bluntly tell her that it is unacceptable for her to alter your
projects. I haven't ever had to actually deal with anything like this since
I don't send any artwork home until the end of the year, so maybe someone
has other ideas that have worked. Good luck!
K-12 Kansas Art Teacher

> What do you think about this....... I had the Kinders turn a heavy
> stuffed paper bag into a Spooky house for Halloween. They patterned
> different lines onto orange paper for the roofs.(which I stapled on)
> They drew, Sharpied, cut out, and glued Halloween decorations (ghosts,
> pumpkins, mummies, chimney, door, and bats) onto the bag. They were
> cute as could be. I sent the Spooky houses back to class with the
> kids so that they would take them home and be part of their home decor
> for Halloween. It turns out that once the houses were back in their
> own classroom their teacher had them add die-cut ghosts, stickers,
> etc. All of the additions were machine made. She never mentioned it
> to me until after the kids took them home. My real question is....was
> she out of line to have her students work on them again, what message
> was she sending with the perfect machine made shapes?

To unsubscribe go to