Note: To protect the privacy of our members, e-mail addresses have been removed from the archived messages. As a result, some links may be broken.

Find Lesson Plans on! GettyGames

LD's was RE: Gifted Student(?)


From: Kimberly Herbert (kimberly_at_TeacherArtExchange)
Date: Fri Mar 02 2001 - 05:11:10 PST

I agree and disagree with you at the same time. I wish that in the US we
would recognize different learning styles not learning disabilities (except
in extreme cases with organic causes.) On the other hand I wish I had been
diagnosed before university. From 3rd grade through 12th I was called lazy,
sloppy, and unmotivated for my handwriting and inability to spell. At
university I was diagnosed with dysgraphia. Simply knowing there was a
reason why no matter how hard I tried I couldn't get spelling through my
head helped me relax and learn alternative techniques. It would have saved a
lot of heartache if my family and I had known earlier.

I also knew a student at a school I subbed in for 3 years, in 6th grade he
was a happy pretty funny kid by 8th he was a dangerous angry young man. In
elementary school he had been in a motorcycle accident. The doctors said
that the area of the brain that processes symbolic language had sustained a
good deal of damage. His parents refused to allow testing, that would have
allowed the teachers to create a special program to help him work around the
problem. His father was at fault in the accident, but he blamed the boy. If
the boy had been blind there would have been know question, but because the
injury was less visible (it did show up on a CAT scan or MRI) the teachers
had their hands tied behind their backs especially when it came to state
mandated testing.

If we treat an LD diagnoses as the beginning of a solution it is good. If
the LD diagnoses is the stopping point and excuse then it is cruelty to the

Kimberly Herbert (
CAM Administrator
San Angelo Museum of Fine Arts/Children's Art Museum

-----Original Message-----
From: Woody Duncan []
Sent: Friday, March 02, 2001 5:44 AM
To: ArtsEdNet Talk
Subject: Re: Gifted Student(?)

> The Austin's wrote:

> I very possibly have a 2nd grade gifted student that I would really
> like to encourage. This student is LD in reading and math,

It's amazing how they are able to label a child LD or whatever at such
an early age. Those labels stick for life. We are all gifted in some way.

> We don't have a gifted program in our area,
> so I'm kind of on my own.

But you do have a "Gifted Program" it's the art class.
Encourage her and give her support and make sure she gets
that encouragement and support at home.

> TIA ~Michal

                I'm from Kansas,  where the voters threw out
     the monkeys and evolution may soon be taught in schools
                       To respond to me privately via E-mail
                           click on
           put Hey Woody on the subject line so I'll read it first
You are welcome to visit my Web Site at
  This E-mail message is from Artist/Teacher Woody Duncan
             Rosedale Middle School in Kansas City, Kansas
     the new URL for school is
to see the newest photos of my beautiful grandkids Tim, Tess and Tiff
               click on
to see a virtual field trip of KC go to
to see Rosedale's best go to
to visit our community garden go to