Note: To protect the privacy of our members, e-mail addresses have been removed from the archived messages. As a result, some links may be broken.

Find Lesson Plans on! GettyGames

Re: [teacherartexchange] Teaching idea development?


From: Patricia Knott (pknott_6_at_TeacherArtExchange)
Date: Mon Jun 29 2009 - 15:12:59 PDT

  Having been an artist for 20 some years before I became a teacher
--- I have always been "idea- based."
I employ a "choice-based" art room where I give a problem to solve
and the innovation of the solutions is the basis for assessment. Of
course that means I have to provide many avenues for research. and
guidance as to how the solution is reached,.
When the focus is on student ideas-- the product reflects the
student input. in a positive manner.
I search for ideas first, then give individualized or group
instruction as to best means for technique. I will sometimes present
a technique that all have to follow, but never is it in a "style of
lesson. "

  I think it is very important to present methods of achieving a
communication, but I think it is more important to foster idea
generation. The art world revolves around what is new and
different. if we are not asking kids how to ask questions then we
are not teaching anything.

If we focus on techniques that may or may not have not value anymore,
then we sacrifice time to generate ideas that may get students to
look and observe and question on their own. All thinking about
education, is that is be student directed so they can realize the
skills from one discipline to another.
Problem solving is the core concept. That may mean we have to
change our concepts of "standards." If the "idea" doesn't come first
I don't now what should.

I can't ever envision going back to DBAE. I did that for couple of
years because it was the thing to do. But it left me cold and
  Give plenty of history, give plenty of methods, but mix it up
enough so that students can make a decision and apply it to their

student reflection is very important -- they need to evaluate the
choices in order to make connections

Not easy for sure, and sometimes messy


On Jun 27, 2009, at 8:56 PM, Diane Beilby wrote:

> Teachers
> I need help!,
> I am in a methods class and an writing a research paper. For my
> paper I
> need input from other art teachers.
> I need some data. I am hoping that some of you might answer a few
> questions
> for me.
> I have been teaching art for 13 years. When I began it seems the
> focus was
> on technique and design principles. I was attracted to Discipline
> based art
> education. I have gradually been changing my focus from design
> first to
> idea first then design and technique.
> Do you teach idea development in your class? Do you base
> assignments on
> technique, design principles and/or idea development? Has your
> class focus
> been changing? If you have been changing your focus, do you notice
> more
> involvement with lessons where students base assignments on their
> ideas
> instead design or technique alone.
> Thanks in advance for any input
> Diane
> ---
> To unsubscribe go to
> teacherartexchange/unsubscribe.html

To unsubscribe go to