Note: To protect the privacy of our members, e-mail addresses have been removed from the archived messages. As a result, some links may be broken.

Find Lesson Plans on! GettyGames

Re: art survey, please respond


Date: Thu Jun 17 2004 - 04:49:04 PDT

My comments refer to my experience teaching elementary choice-based art since

1.  What techniques or activities have you found to be most successful in
sparking creativity?
Offering a safe creative space, telling students EXPLICITLY that their ideas
will be the content of their art work and that I am there to offer techniques
and materials that can help them say visually what they need to say.  You have
no idea how engaging that can be.  Also, the celebration of mistakes and
false starts as an INTEGRAL part of the art process: no fear!  Art work is made
more difficult when students fear making a mistake; much more so when they are
graded down for it.

2.  What techniques or practices do you use to increase student thinking
Choice teaching gives broad responsibility to students.  It is much easier to
be told what to do all the time: choice students must access their inner
resources to a much greater degree.  As each work is quite unique, offering unique
challenges, the students are more challenged to solve the problems inplicit
in the work.  Students also see and discuss the problem solving which takes
place in the work of their colleagues which may differ enormously from their own
work.  There is relatively little problem solving in an art room project in
which the students follow the teacher steps one by one--the teacher has already
solved most of the problems and the students duplicate her methods.

3.  What teaching techniques have been most successful in your classroom for
reaching a variety of learners?
Choice teaching encourages students to leverage their unique strengths in
deciding about their art.  Even the most disabled students who have been in my
room over thirty years have had places where they were the most comfortable. 
Gaining confidence working in areas of their strengths often gave them the
courage to work in areas more difficult to them.  Independent work is often not
available to children having difficulty in school; choice teaching offers this
important practice.
(among my students since 1972: legally blind, deaf, cerebral palsy, brittle
bone disease, hemophilia, wheelchair bound, Asperger's syndrome, Austism,
emotionally disturbed, PDD, fetal alcohol syndrome, low IQ and numerous ADD and HD
students, students who could not read, etc.)  I have students who work well in
self created collaborative groups, students who must work alone, students who
work quickly, students who work slowly, students who are impulsive, students
who are fanatical planners, and so on and on.  Peer teaching is also
enormously helpful to our students.

4.  how does the physical organization of your room help to spark creativity
and address a variety of learning styles? The room stays the same year in year
out.  Bulletin boards are not decorations, but serve as permanent references
of vocab., menus of materials, procedures, color wheels, etc etc.  Students
know how to find their materials, how to put them away. They know what is
available before they arrive so that they usually come knowing what they will make
for their art idea.

5.  Is your classroom more student centered or teacher centered? Absolutely
student centered; however as teacher I create a strong structure of the room
set up, the sequence of demonstrations and the art making spirit necessary for
the room to function.  It is not chaotic.

6.  Taking into account the six national visual arts standards, which do you
think are the most important?  (rate from one to six, one being least
important and six being most important)

Let me say that from what I observe, #s 6 and 4 are the most important in
many school systems as they are the easiest to "do" if one is not connected to
personal art processes. They are also easier to grade. They are the parts of
DBAE that I saw many art teachers grab on to. They frequently result in what
Peter London calls "secondhand art".  Someone else has had an aesthetic experience
which students must then duplicate. And the study of art history, timelines,
etc is a great domain but it is a left-brained occupation, quite different
from art making.

1)Understand and apply visual arts media, techniques, and processes. Number
one: I still say that with younger students they must DO first before any of
the rest of it is of particular interest.

2)Use knowledge of visual arts structures and functions.  Nuumber four:
Students will use these elements and principals in the course of their work and if
teachers highlight those in that context, children learn them easily.

3)Choose and evaluate a range of subject matter, symbols, and ideas. Number
two if it means that the students will actually be choosing.  Very few art
programs actually do this.

4)Understand the visual arts in relation to history and culture. I put four
and six together, but the info is seamless; we are always making
connections--measuring, using math, being inspired by writing or film to make a painting,
dancing the brush over the paper...and students learn about architects,
political poster creators, illustrators, industrial designers as part of the teacher
comments on their independent work.

5)Reflect upon and assess the characteristics and merit of their work, and
the work of others. Number three: and with all students it MUST begin with their
own work, that reflection.  Artists must constantly evaluate and reflect in
order to work through each piece; it is internal and ongoing. When students
have chosen the work they reflect and speak about it easily; next level is
looking at artwork of peers, then on to the work of others.  Students will connect
to master artists who follow lines of thought which are interesting to them.

6)Make connections between visual arts and other disciplines. see #4

Kathy Douglas