Note: To protect the privacy of our members, e-mail addresses have been removed from the archived messages. As a result, some links may be broken.

Find Lesson Plans on! GettyGames

Re: [teacherartexchange] Rubrics also long


From: Patricia Knott (pknott_6_at_TeacherArtExchange)
Date: Tue Feb 12 2008 - 12:54:59 PST

Jane reminds of when Standards were introduced and we were TOLD to
show examples of exemplary, proficient, etc......

I cringed and covered my eyes-- How dare we??????? How did we
forget the exploration??????
Here's what I'm working on ( and I stole this from somewhere I
don"t remember where):

When confronted with a problem, I spend time gathering information
about it from several sources:

I ask questions to get more information:

I examine beliefs, assumptions and opinions and weigh use them to
inform my work:

I refrain from making judgements or decisions until I've considered
all options.:

I try to see the merits of others' opinions even if they are
different from mine:

I enjoy finding new solutions to problems:

For this project I

If we are to continue to advocate that art fosters critical thinking
then we MUST ask the thinking questions. More and more my assessment
is about the process and not the product. I teach high school and I
am sick to death of kids with so much to say stifled by conventions
and what they think is expected. I am sick to death of slick
technique over idea. And I'm sick to death of lessons that mimic
instead of asking the "what if" questions.


On Feb 12, 2008, at 3:28 PM, wrote:

> When assessment started to be a serious discussion for art teachers,
> a video example made my blood boil. The assignment was to make a
> "whisper box" out of paper. Just an empty cube of paper. And to
> decorate it "appropriately." Then the box examples were rated. Some
> were colorful and school-art "pleasing" as Patty described, you
> know, PLEASING.
> One box was covered with little pencil scratches and runes, very
> lightly, hard to make out. In other words, a perfect whisper box...
> So, when you make an assignment, think: what should students know
> and be able to do for an "appropriate" outcome?
> One time an AP told me she wanted every single thing every single
> student did in art to have a rubric of 20 items to rate attached,
> every day. Let's see, 150 students a day, five days a week times
> the daily work efforts in a 40 minute period times 20 items to
> assess and each of those 20 items had 4 rating categories...
> So make the rubric useful and sensible, and hand a duplicate to the
> student to fill out for self-assessment.
> Given the project description, students can write what they intended
> to make/do and how they think it turned out; What might they do
> differently next time? As for skill evaluation, What did they do
> best? What do they need to work on?
> Be simple, be specific. And as my granny would say: Good, better,
> best, never let it rest, 'till your good is better and your better
> best!
> To all who assess, best wishes. Jane in Brooklyn
> ---
> To unsubscribe go to

To unsubscribe go to