I don't know of one that exists - but this would be the perfect activity
for a voicethread or wiki page.
There have been some discussions here about both.
With voicethread you can have your students upload images of their work
- they can type or record comments. Invite others to view and leave
comments. I love voicethread.
You can do the same with wikis - upload images -include an artist
statement if you want - others can view and add to the discussion.
I have seen student work on voicethread... but nothing with organized
You can make wikis private (for free through wikispaces - and you can
create log ins and passwords without student e-mails, you would have to
extend invitations and permissions for outside viewers), voicethread has
an educators site too - but you have to pay to make it private. ($60)
then you have to invite people.
Both are super simple to use - I have 6 wiki pages for classes, and I
have a voicethread account.
Other on-line groups require that kids are at least 13 with e-mail
accounts. Harder to supervise discussions.
depends on your age group and how much control you want - if it is to
teach critiquing you will prefer one over another - if it is to expose
them to more - you will want something else.
If you have any questions, let me know.
From: Keith Wilde [mailto:email@example.com]
Sent: Friday, April 24, 2009 9:47 AM
To: TeacherArtExchange Discussion Group
Subject: [teacherartexchange] Online Art Criticism Between Students -
Does it Exist?
I would like to create an opportunity for my high school students to
partner with other schools online for critique of student work and art
appreciation activities. I think it would be great if students were
able to post their work online and receive questions and feedback from
other students. They could return the favor as well. Does anyone out
there do this already? Are there existing online venues for this? Are
there ways to find schools interested in forming a partnership?