Madonna Adoring the Child with Musical Angels

Object Details

Title:

Madonna Adoring the Child with Musical Angels

Artist/Maker:

Bernardino Zenale (Italian, about 1456 - 1526)

Culture:

Italian

Date:

about 1502

Medium:

Oil on panel

Dimensions:

143.5 x 85.7 cm (56 1/2 x 33 3/4 in.)

See more

See less

Arms crossed in veneration, a youthful Virgin Mary bows her head and looks solemnly at her infant son. He in turn looks out and makes the sign of benediction toward her. In a strikingly human gesture, an angel gently holds the shoulder and side of the unsteady child, ensuring that he does not topple forward. Angels on either side of the scene play musical instruments; a trio of angels above kneel on a cloud and sing in accompaniment. The scene takes place under a vaulted ceiling supported by pilasters with Corinthian capitals. Bernardino Zenale's modeling of the figures and his depiction of a misty landscape derived from Leonardo da Vinci's style.

This painting was originally the central panel of an altarpiece in the chapel of the Immaculate Conception in San Francesco, Cantù, Italy. The two side panels depicting various saints are now in museums in Milan.

Provenance
about 1502 - 1777

Convento dei Francescani (Cantù, Italy), possibly commissioned from the artist.

- 1873

Michele Cavalieri (Milan, Italy), sold to Enrico Cernuschi, 1873.

1873 - 1900

Enrico Cernuschi (Paris, France) [sold, Cernuschi sale, Chevallier, Duchesne, Paris, May 25, 1900, lot 81.]

by 1923 - 1929

Sir Joseph Benjamin Robinson, 1st Bart., 1840 - 1929 (London, England; Hawthornden, Cape Peninsula, South Africa) [unsold, Robinson sale, Christie's, London, July 6, 1923, lot 34], by inheritance to his daughter, Princess Ida Louise Labia, 1929.

1929 - 1961

Ida Louise, Princess Labia, 1879 - 1961 (Cape Town, South Africa), by inheritance to her sons Count Natale Labia and Dr. Joseph Labia.

1961 - still in 1962

Natale, Count Labia

1961 - still in 1962

and Dr. Joseph Labia

- 1971

French and Company, Inc. (New York, New York), sold to the J. Paul Getty Museum, 1971.

Exhibitions
The Robinson Collection: Paintings from the Collection of the Late Sir J. B. Robinson, Bt., Lent by the Princess Labia (July 2 to September 14, 1958) (Cat. 19)
  • Royal Academy of Arts (London), July 2 to September 14, 1958
The Sir Joseph Robinson Collection: Lent by the Princess Labia (1959) (Cat. 3)
  • National Gallery of South Africa (Cape Town), 1959
Sammlung Sir Joseph Robinson, 1840 - 1929: Werke europäischer Malerei vom 15. bis 19. Jahrhundert (August 17 to September 16, 1962) (Cat. 2)
  • Kunsthaus Zürich (Zurich), August 17 to September 16, 1962
Zenale e Leonardo: Tradizione e Rinnovamento della pittura Lombarda (December 4, 1982 to February 28, 1983) (Cat. 1c)
  • Museo Poldi Pezzoli (Milan), December 4, 1982 to February 28, 1983
Bibliography

Chevallier, Duchesne, and Haro, Paris. Catalogue des tableaux anciens [...] provenant de la Collection Cernuschi. May 25-26, 1900 lot 81, ill.

Ffoulkes, Constance, and Rodolfo Maiocchi. Vincenzo Foppa of Brescia, Founder of the Lombard School: His Life and Work (London: John Lane, 1909) p. 249n1.

Suida, Wilhelm. "Leonardo da Vinci und seine Schüle in Mailand." Monatshefte für Kunstwissenschaft 12, no. 10/11 (Oct.-Nov., 1919) pp. 268, pl. 70, fig. 15.

Christie, Manson & Woods, London. Catalogue of the Well-Known Collection of Pictures by Old Masters of Sir Joseph B. Robinson, Bart. of South Africa. July 6, 1923 lot. 34.

Waterhouse, Ellis Kirkham. Notebooks, 67 vols., 1924-85, Los Angeles, Getty Research Institute, accession no. 870204 vol. 55, p. 89 (February 1981).

Berenson, Bernard. Italian Pictures of the Renaissance: A List of the Principal Artists and Their Works with an Index of Places (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1932) p. 150.

"The Robinson Pictures." Connoisseur 142, no. 572 (November 1958) p. 96, no. 19.

Scharf, Alfred. "The Robinson Collection." The Burlington Magazine 100, no. 666 (September 1958) p. 302-3, fig. 5.

The Robinson Collection. Paintings from the Collection of the Late Sir J. B. Robinson, Bt., lent by the Princess Labia, exh. cat. (London: Royal Academy of Arts, 1958) p. 15, no. 19.

The Robinson Collection. Paintings from the collection of the late Sir J. B. Robinson, Bt., now in the possession of the Princess Labia (London: Royal Academy of Arts, 1958) pl. 3.

Paris, John. The Sir Joseph Robinson Collection. Lent by the Princess Labia, exh. cat. (Cape Town: National Gallery of South Africa, 1959) p. 2, no. 3.

Ferrari, Marialuisa. "Lo pseudo Civerchio e Bernardo Zenale." Paragone 127 (July 1960) pp. 40-1, 63n9-10, fig. 26.

Sammlung Sir Joseph Robinson (1840-1929): Werke europäischer Malerei vom 15. bis 19. Jahrhundert, exh. cat. (Zürich: Kunsthaus, 1962) pp. 11-12, no. 2.

Berenson, Bernard. Italian Pictures of the Renaissance: A List of the Principal Artists and Their Works with an Index of Places. Vol. 1, Central Italian and North Italian Schools (New York: Phaidon, 1968) p. 89.

Romano, Giovanni, ed. Musei del Piemonte: opera d'arte restaurate, exh. cat. (Turin: Palazzo della Società Promotrice delle Belle Arti al Valentino, 1978) p. 74 (under no.18), entry by P. Loiacono Astrua.

Carlevaro, Giovanna. "Materiale per lo studio di Bernardo Zenale." Arte Lombarda, n.s., 63 (1982-1983) pp. 63-65, no. 20, fig. 26.

Museo Poldi Pezzoli: Dipinti (Milan: Electa Editrice, 1982) pp. 80-1, under nos. 22-3.

Zenale e Leonardo: Tradizione e rinnovamento della pittura lombarda, exh. cat. (Milan: Museo Poldi Pezzoli, 1982) pp. 11, 13, 24-49, ill.

Neilson, Nancy Ward. Review of Zenale e Leonardo. Museo Poldi Pezzoli, Milan. The Burlington Magazine 125, no. 961 (April 1983) pp. 246-7.

Marani, Pietro C. Leonardo e i leonardeschi a Brera (Florence: Cantini, 1987) p. 109, under no. 12.

Natale, Mauro, and Maria Teresa Binaghi Olivari. "Dagli esordi alla fine del Rinascimento. Butinone e Zenale." In Pittura tra Adda e Serio: Lodi, Treviglio, Caravaggio, Crema. Mina Gregori, ed. (Milan: Cariplo, 1987) pp. 122, 140, 166-7, fig. 66.

Fiorio, Maria Teresa. "La pittura del Cinquecento nei territori di Milano e Cremona." In La pittura in Italia: Il Cinquecento. Giuliano Briganti, ed. 2 vols. (Milan: Electa, 1988), vol. 1 pp. 66, 75, fig. 76.

Leone de Castris, Pierluigi. "La pittura del Cinquecento nell'Italia meridionale." In La Pittura in Italia: Il Cinquecento. Giuliano Briganti, ed. 2 vols. (Milan: Electa, 1988), vol. 2 p. 476.

Romano, Giovanni, ed. Piemontesi e Lombardi tra Quattrocento e Cinquecento, exh. cat. (Turin: Antichi Maestri Pittori, 1989) pp. 75-6, 78-9, under no. 11, entry by Marco Tanzi.

Pujmanová, Olga. "A 'Flagellation' by Bernardo Zenale in Prague." The Burlington Magazine 132, no. 1048 (July 1990) p. 494.

Navarro, Fausta. "Zenale 1510: La Flagellazione di Praga." In Tra Metodo e Ricerca: Contributi di Storia dell'Arte: Atti del Seminario di Studio in ricordo de Maria Luisa Ferrari (Lecce, 22/23 marzo 1988) (Galatina: Congedo Editore, 1991) p. 97.

Norris, Andrea S. "Bernardo Zenale, 'Madonna and Saints'." The Register of the Spencer Museum of Art 6, nos. 8-9 (1991-1992) pp. 41, 43, 46, 48, fig. 4.

Shell, Janice. "Bernardo Zenale." In The Dictionary of Art. Jane Turner, ed. Vol. 33 (London: Macmillan Publishers Limited, 1996) p. 633-4, ill.

Jaffé, David. Summary Catalogue of European Paintings in the J. Paul Getty Museum (Los Angeles: J. Paul Getty Museum, 1997) p. 138, ill.

Milesi, Silvana. Butinone-Zenale e la pittura a Bergamo dal Duecento al Quattrocento (Bergamo: Corponove Editrice, 1997) pp. 29, 178, ill.

Shell, Janice. "Bernardo Zenale." In Encyclopedia of Italian Renaissance & Mannerist Art. Jane Turner, ed. Vol. 2 (New York: Grove's Dictionaries, Inc., 2000) pp. 1796-97, ill.

Bandera, Sandrina. "Inattese e gratificanti sorprese di una campagna di restauro: la scoperta di un affresco sconosciuto. Bernardo Zenale alla Certosa di Garegnano." In Arte Lombarda del Secondo Millennio (Milan: Federico Motta, 2000) pp. 109-10.

Agosti, Giovanni, Mauro Natale, and Giovanni Romano, eds. Vincenzo Foppa: Un protagonista del Rinascimento, exh. cat. (Brescia: Santa Giulia Museo della Città, 2002) p. 172.

Bandera, Sandrina. "Testimonianze pittoriche rinascimentali nel territorio di Abbiategrasso." In Rinascimento Ritrovato: La chiesa e il convento di Santa Maria Annunziata ad Abbiategrasso. Pierluigi De Vecchi and Giulio Bora, eds. (Milan: Skira, 2007) pp. 163, 166, 178, fig. 15.

Natale, Mauro, ed. Foppa, Zenale and Luini: Lombard Painters before and after Leonardo, exh. cat. (London: Robilant + Voena, 2012) p. 80, under no. 13.